Showing posts with label Jill Stein. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Jill Stein. Show all posts

Sunday, October 27, 2019

Chile Protests, Federal Election Results, Evo Morales Wins & more -- The Week in News, Opinion and Videos October 20 - 27


This week's list of articles, news items, opinion pieces and videos that I see as a must if you are looking for a roundup that should be of interest to The Left Chapter readers.



This list covers the week of October 20 - 27.

1) Over 1 Million People March in Chile's Largest Protest

Telesur 

Over one million people are marching in the streets of the Chilean capital, responding to the convocation of students and labor unions who organized on social media "The Largest March in Chile" on Friday afternoon, with rallies paralyzing major cities.

- "the right to live in peace".
Victor Jara.

✊🏽🌹❤️

#porunavidadigna



One million in the streets of Santiago, Chile today to protest the austerity program of the right-wing Pinera government and the army/police repression of the people!



2) Chile Unrest: Rights Groups Warn of Dictatorship-Like Practices

Telesur

In Chile 2,138 people have been arrested, including 243 minors and 407 women, 9 of whom were stripped during police procedures, according to the National Institute of Human Rights (NHRI).

The popular movement against Piñera’s neoliberal government and its repressive policies, is unprecedented in Chile’s modern history, and it has grown stronger following the beginning of a 48 hours general strike called by several social organizations.



Day 7. Santiago. Over 500 thousand in the streets.






Latin American is rising up against Neoliberalism.



3) Chile Protesters Tortured, Sexually Abused by Security Forces: Report

Telesur 

The National Institute of Human Rights in Chile (INDH) has confirmed that they have received cases of possible torture at the hands of the authorities amid protests that began against public transport fare hikes but have extended into an uprising against President Piñera’s neoliberal policies.

4) Chile: Popular revolt exposes a violent economic system

Pablo Leighton, Green Left Weekly 

Countless symbols of neoliberalism came under attack during protests in Chile over the October 18–20 long weekend.

5) In Chile, Protesters Continue To Defy The President And Military

Paige Sutherland, NPR

Massive protests have continued over economic inequality in Chile this week, defying the president and security forces' efforts to restore calm. The widespread and sometimes violent unrest has led to more than a dozen deaths.

Demonstrations have now turned into a general protest against neoliberalism in Chile.



6) Chile Faces Mine Stoppages as Workers Join Protests

Laura Millan Lombrana, Bloomberg

Anti-government protests that have shaken the world’s largest copper producing nation Chile for the past three days have spread to the mining sector as unions call for stoppages.

7) Chile: State Violence Leads to 1,420 Arrests and 11 Deaths

Telesur 

Chile's National Institute of Human Rights (NHRI) presented on Monday night the latest statistics of detainees and injured since the social protests began on October 17th. According to its report, there have been 1,420 arrests and 84 people wounded by gunfire so far.

8) 'So Awful': Military Returns to Streets in Chile as Unrest Simmers

Andrea Germanos, Common Dreams 

Demonstrators in Chile continued their "pots and pans" protests Sunday following a week of unrest that saw hundreds arrested and the military patrolling the streets for the first time in decades.

In what appears to be amateur video, here is more footage of military personnel in Santiago yesterday shooting an unarmed protester.



Military shooting people in the streets of Santiago, Chile.




9) Swiss elections: Landslide Green gains tip parliament to the left

Urs Geiser, Swiss Info

Green parties have made historic gains at the expense of those to the right and the left in elections to the Swiss parliament.

10) Free Public Transit is Key to a Green New Deal: Free Transit for Toronto

Herman Rosenfeld, Socialist Project Bullet 

One of the few identifiable issues raised in the Canadian election campaign so far is the need to address the climate crisis. The concept of a Green New Deal has been raised by the left and environmental movements across the continent, in Canada through Greenpeace’s Pact for a Green New Deal and obliquely through the NDP (“A New Deal for Climate Action and Good Jobs”), and the Greens (“Green Climate Action Plan”). Addressing the climate emergency has become a theme for all the main parties, even in the cynical and flawed manner of Justin Trudeau and Andrew Scheer.

11) Abortion and same-sex marriage legalised in Northern Ireland, despite DUP opposition

Elly Badcock, Counterfire 

Activists in Northern Ireland celebrated the legalisation of abortion and same-sex marriage at the stroke of midnight, as a cynical last-ditch attempt by unionist parties to restore the executive failed. The Stormont Assembly has now been defunct for over two years, prompted in large part by DUP leader and First Minister Arlene Foster refusing to stand aside after being embroiled in the ‘Cash for Ash’ scandal, where businesses were allowed to exploit green energy incentives and gain taxpayer-funded subsidies. RTE reported that some businesses were receiving £1.60 in subsidies for every £1 they spent on energy, and investigations uncovered businesses running up to ten boilers in order to make millions from these subsidies.

12) Everyone Is a Russian Asset

Matt Taibbi, Rolling Stone

Rather than confront the devastating absurdity of defeat before an ad-libbing game show host who was seemingly trying to lose – a black comedy that is 100% in America’s rich stupidity tradition – Democrats have gone all-in on this theory of foreign infiltration. House speaker Nancy Pelosi even said as much in a White House meeting, pointing at Trump and proclaiming: “All roads lead to Putin.”

13) Hillary Clinton's attacks on Tulsi Gabbard are embarrassing

Nathan Robinson, The Guardian 

Hillary Clinton has kept a relatively low profile since her embarrassing 2016 election defeat, popping up only occasionally to make out-of-touch elitist comments that confirm why she lost. So it was somewhat surprising to hear her weigh in on the 2020 Democratic primary with a truly bizarre comment about (of all people) Tulsi Gabbard.

14) Hillary Clinton called me a 'Russian asset'. The establishment is losing its grip

Jill Stein, The Guardian

The McCarthyist smear against the Green party shows the lengths to which Clinton will go to blame others for her 2016 defeat.




15) Iraqi Security Forces Killed 149 People In Recent Protests, Inquiry Concludes

Richard Gonzales, NPR

Iraqi security forces killed 149 people and wounded over 3,000 in protests that began Oct. 1, a government-appointed inquiry announced Tuesday.

16) Uruguay: Leftist 'Broad Front' Leads Polls With 38% of Vote

Telesur

Less than a week before the presidential elections in Uruguay, citizens' support for the Broad Front, Frente Amplio (FA), a coalition of left-wing organizations which is currently in government, is growing and widening its distance from the opposition led by the center-right National Party (PN).

17) Uruguayans Vote for President, Leftist Candidate Leads Polls

Telesur

Uruguayans voted Sunday in general elections with the Frente Amplio, which has ruled for more than 14 years as a favorite, but their center-left policies face the challenge of a coalition of conservative parties.

18) Jewish Leaders Arrested For Protesting Trump One Year After Mass Shooting at Pittsburgh Synagogue

Democracy Now

Ahead of Trump’s arrival in Pittsburgh on Wednesday, police arrested 14 people as they held a sit-in protest blocking a bridge near the Shale Insight Conference. The protest was led by Jewish leaders who marched behind a banner reading “Our solidarity will defeat White Nationalism.” It came almost exactly one year after a gunman armed with an AR-15 assault rifle opened fire inside the Tree of Life Synagogue in Pittsburgh, killing 11 worshipers. Just ahead of the shooting, the gunman posted a racist screed echoing President Trump’s language about an “invasion” of immigrants. This is Dove Kent of the group Jewish Action, who led Wednesday’s protest.

19) 'Together we are powerful' – McDonald's workers announce biggest wave of fast food strikes Britain has seen

Marcus Barnett, The Morning Star

MCDONALD’S workers have warned bosses that “together we are powerful” as they announce the biggest wave of fast food strikes Britain has ever seen.

20) History falsified as Europe says Nazis and communists are the same

Phil Katz, People's World

When I wrote my book, Freedom From Tyranny, the “Prague Declaration on European Conscience and Communism”—which in terms of falsifying history ranks up there with the Protocols of the Elders of Zion—was still taking shape.

European countries increasingly miss communism.


21) “Unprecedented” Protests Rage Across Lebanon as People Demand PM’s Resignation and End to Austerity

Democracy Now

Mass protests in Lebanon have entered their sixth day as hundreds of thousands around the country are taking to the streets to demonstrate against dire economic conditions, austerity and corruption, demanding the country’s leaders step down. The protests were sparked last week when the government announced a tax on WhatsApp calls, but the massive demonstrations have since grown into a call for revolution. More than a million demonstrators flooded the streets of Beirut, Tripoli and other cities over the weekend. Prime Minister Saad Hariri revoked the WhatsApp tax on Monday and announced a package of economic reforms, but protesters are continuing to call for his ouster. For more, we speak with independent Lebanese journalist Kareem Chehayeb, whose recent piece for The Washington Post is headlined “Lebanon’s protests and wildfires tell the same grim story.”

22) Lebanese Communist Party calls for a general strike

SOL International

The Lebanese Communist Party encourages the people to escalate the uprising and calls for a general strike to force the government to resign.

23) Lebanon Protesters Back in the Streets

Telesur

Protesters poured back onto streets and squares across Lebanon on Saturday, despite army efforts to unblock roads, with no end in sight to a crisis that has virtually shut down the nation for the past 10 days as demonstrators demand the government leaders resign. 

24) An inside account of the Indigenous uprising in Ecuador

Michael Otto and Zoila Ramirez, IAC

On Oct. 7, 4000 Indigenous people from towns in and around the same canton marched for four hours to Ibarra to present a manifesto to the governor of Imbabura. The governor refused to meet with them and later rejected their primary demands: Cease the military aggression against Indigenous communities and support their resistance to the “paquetazo” (economic package) ordered by the International Monetary Fund and Decree 883, which removed fuel subsidies.

25) Ecuador: Indigenous Organizations Propose a People's Parliament

Telesur

The Confederation of Indigenous Nationalities of Ecuador (Conaie) on Thursday convened to form a popular parliament so as to outline an economic model and present it to President Lenin Moreno.

26) Bolivia: Morales Officially Wins Presidency

Telesur 

With 99.99 percent of the votes counted in Bolivia, Evo Morales is once again president of the Andean country with 47.07 percent of the votes.

27) Morales Calls on Opposition Groups To Respect Electoral Result

Telesur

Bolivia experienced on Friday a full day of strikes led by opposition groups who were dissatisfied with the results of the presidential elections that took place on  October 20. The election saw an important victory for President Evo Morales who won with 47.08% of the votes.

28) Mexico Condemns OAS Interference in Bolivia's Elections

Telesur

The Mexican government has criticised the OAS Electoral Observation Mission (MOE) for prematurely raising ‘concerns’ about Bolivia’s elections before carrying out a full audit which the Bolivian government invited them to do. 

29) Boycott Puma protests to take place after brand sponsors Israel

The Morning Star

HUMAN rights activists are to protest outside sportswear brand Puma’s stores, offices and sponsored teams’ events across the world today against the company’s sponsorship of the Israeli Football Association (IFA).

30) Activists declare victory in #RaptorsDontGo campaign

Marion Kawas, Mondoweiss 

The Canadian BDS Coalition issued a statement on October 22, 2019, declaring victory in the campaign to stop the NBA 2019 champions, the Toronto Raptors, from going as a team on a “promised trip” to Israel. The Coalition noted that the new 2019-20 National Basketball Association NBA season has officially started, and “no reported public team visit” to Israel has occurred.

31) Spain: Sanchez Backs Security Forces in Catalonia Crackdown

Telesur

In the middle of the political crisis that has hit Catalonia for the last eight days, Spanish Prime Minister Pedro Sanchez visited Barcelona Monday, where he expressed his full support to the police officers dealing with the protests and warned them that the current situation will be longspun.

32) MINORITY GOVERNMENT: STRONG EXTRA-PARLIAMENTARY MOVEMENT NEEDED TO FORCE GAINS

People's Voice

Throughout this election campaign, opinion polls projected the probability of a minority government. It was a scenario that many progressives anticipated with relish, in the hopes that it would provide a strong opportunity for the labour and people’s movements to win meaningful reforms.

(Related: The NDP's election disaster shows again the need for something new on the left)

33) Trudeau rules out coalition, promises gender equity in new cabinet

Kathleen Harris · CBC News

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau today ruled out a governing coalition and said his minority government's new cabinet will have gender balance when it's sworn in on Nov. 20.

34) Trudeau extends olive branch to Western Canada, vows to build Trans Mountain despite opposition

 John Paul Tasker, CBC News

Two days after much of Western Canada rejected the Liberals on election day, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau today vowed to be more sensitive to the needs of Alberta and Saskatchewan and to build the Trans Mountain expansion pipeline in the face of entrenched opposition from environmentalists.

(Related: No, the NDP losing over 600,000 votes and 20 seats is not a "victory")

35) ELECTION RESULTS NO EXCUSE FOR NATIONAL CHAUVINISM

Dave McKee, People's Voice

As the votes were being counted on October 21, it quickly became clear that the NDP was not going to see its much anticipated (and expected) breakthrough in Toronto. For the last two weeks of the campaign, polls consistently suggested that New Democrats were on track to win in the downtown ridings of Toronto Danforth, Parkdale-High Park, and Davenport. In the end, it wasn’t even close – the Liberals won the first two ridings by 8000 and 10,000 votes, respectively, and held Davenport by a close-but-comfortable 1500.

36) Oil Chauvinism and the Western NDP Schism

Dock Currie


The schism between the Federal NDP and the Alberta NDP cannot be, and should not be, papered over. It represents a real, material disagreement, and, in the case of the Alberta NDP, a massive departure from the policies and principles of the Federal NDP.

Sunday, December 24, 2017

Nepal, Israel, Venezuela, Honduras and more -- The Left Chapter Sunday Reading List December 17 - 24

This week's list of articles, news items and opinion pieces that I see as must reads if you are looking for a roundup that should be of interest to The Left Chapter readers.

This list covers the week of  December 17 - 24.  It is generally in order of the date of the article's release.


This installment has 2 entries that are from before the period. They have been integrated into the post.

1) The problem with consent

Tamar Dina, The Coast

Women’s role in sex is still primarily framed—in the legal system and in society—as gatekeeper to men’s desires.

Read the full article.

2) Pleasure Machines: What Sex Robots Tell Us About Men and Sex

Caitlin Roper, ABC

In a culture of institutionalised male dominance, men have created replicas of women for the express purpose of enacting their fantasies.

Read the full article.

3) Reckoning with a culture of male resentment

 Dayna Tortorici, The Guardian

In the face of a male backlash to the recent debate over sexual harassment, is it time to accept that some will find the world less comfortable in the process of making it habitable for others?

Read the full article.

4) Society still has a problem with women speaking out. Look at Kate Maltby

Abi Wilkinson, The Guardian

Women have long paid a price for confronting these sorts of issues. Following sexual harassment allegations against Damian Green, Maltby’s already facing trial by media.

Read the full article.

5) Ta-Nehisi Coates is the neoliberal face of the black freedom struggle

Cornel West, The Guardian

Ta-Nehisi Coates’ We Were Eight Years in Power, a book about Barack Obama’s presidency and the tenacity of white supremacy, has captured the attention of many of us. One crucial question is why now in this moment has his apolitical pessimism gained such wide acceptance?

Read the full article.

6) Vindicated Halifax firefighter Liane Tessier: I want the truth out there, I want to expose the structure of misogyny

Robert Devet, The Nova Scotia Advocate

It’s been a long and difficult battle for justice for former HRM firefighter Liane Tessier, but this coming Monday the City of Halifax and Halifax Regional Fire and Emergency will finally issue an apology. As well, Tessier will receive a settlement of an undisclosed amount.

Read the full article.

7) Communists Sweep the Nepali Elections

Vijay Prashad, Socialist Project Bullet 

You might as well imagine a large red flag fluttering from the summit of Mount Everest. That’s what the outcome of the parliamentary and provincial elections in Nepal suggests. The Communists have won both decisively. In the parliament, the Communist alliance will hold close to a two-thirds majority. The government that this majority forms will not only be able to last the full five year term – the first time this would have happened since Nepal adopted parliamentary democracy in 1990 – but it will be able to revise the 2015 Constitution.

Read the full article.

8) CORPORATIONS SAY PUBLICLY THEY’LL POCKET THE TAX CUT, BUT REPUBLICANS AREN’T LISTENING

Zaid Jilani, The Intercept

Weeks before the Republican-led Congress moved toward final passage of its corporate tax cut bill, major companies had already begun a surge of stock buybacks — confirming critics’ fears that the windfall of lower rates will be used for self-enrichment rather than job growth.

Read the full article.

9) The Israeli Military First Took His Legs, Then His Life

Gideon Levy, Haaretz

The Israeli army sharpshooter couldn’t target the lower part of his victim’s body — Ibrahim Abu Thuraya didn’t have one. The 29-year-old, who worked washing cars and who lived in Gaza City’s Shati refugee camp, lost both legs from the hips down in an Israeli airstrike during Operation Cast Lead in 2008. He used a wheelchair to get around. On Friday the army finished the job: A sharpshooter aimed at his head and shot him dead.

Read the full article.

10) McCarthyite Witch Hunt Comes For Jill Stein

Caitlin Johnstone, Medium

Two days ago I happened to write an article about the amazingly stupid conspiracy theory that the Green Party, which has run a presidential candidate every election since 1996, ran a presidential candidate in 2016 because of a Russian plot to sabotage American democracy. Today, Buzzfeed News reports that the Senate Intelligence Committee has asked Jill Stein’s campaign to comply with a document search.

Read the full article.

11) How Tough Is It to Change a Culture of Harassment? Ask Women at Ford

Susan Chira and Catrin Einhorn, The New York Times

Decades after the company tried to tackle sexual misconduct at two Chicago plants, continued abuse raises questions about the possibility of change.

Read the full article.

12) Chavista vs. Chavista: Class Struggle Comes to the Forefront Following Local Elections

Chris Gilbert, Venezuela Analysis

This past Sunday, on the 187th anniversary of Simón Bolívar's death, grassroots leader Angel Prado voiced the concern that he and his supporters had, like the Venezuelan independence hero, been abandoned by the very state that they helped to build. The reasons for this worry are obvious: Prado, who is a popular Chavista candidate for mayor in Lara state's Simón Planas township, won a landslide victory on December 10 against the government's candidate, only to see that victory taken away by decree.

Read the full article.

13) Russian victims of domestic abuse forced to pay perpetrator’s fine

Marianna Spring, The Guardian

Russian women who are victims of domestic abuse are being forced to pay fines handed down to their abusers, campaigners have said.

Read the full article.

14) Thirty years after Morgentaler ruling on abortion rights, Canada ‘still dealing with the same issues’

Brett Bundale, The Toronto Star

Only one in six hospitals in Canada performs abortions and some provinces have no standalone abortion clinics at all. New Brunswick, meanwhile, continues to refuse to fund abortions at the province’s only clinic.

Read the full article.

15) Israel Tackles Existential Threat Posed By 16-Year-Old Palestinian Girl

Robert Mackey, The Intercept

On Wednesday, an Israeli military court extended the detention of Ahed Tamimi, a 16-year-old girl who has become the face of Palestinian resistance to Israel’s military occupation of the West Bank for many who follow the weekly protests in her village through social media.

Read the full article.

16) 'Long live the Catalan Republic': Secessionists claim victory

Thomson Reuters

The absolute majority won by separatists in a regional election on Thursday was a victory of the "Catalan republic" over the Spanish state, said secessionist leader Carles Puigdemont as the final vote count rolled in.

Read the full article.

17) How Long Does It Take a Southern White Democrat Elected by Black Voters to Shift to the Right? Less Than a Week. 

LaTosha Brown, Rewire

This strategy and faulty thinking by Southern Democrats is short-sighted, unsustainable, and politically ineffective.

Read the full article.

18) Secretive cabinet decision limits sick days for autoworkers

Cristina Howorun and Jessica Bruno, City News

It’s one of the most important sectors in Ontario’s economy, but thanks to a behind-the-scenes government decision, auto workers aren’t getting the same protections as most other people working in this province.

Read the full article.

19) Sweden plans change in law to require explicit consent before sexual contact

Associated Press

Under proposed legislation rape could be proved if accuser had not given verbal agreement or clearly demonstrated desire to engage in sexual activity.

Read the full article.

20) ‘No rapists on our streets’: Hundreds, mostly women, rally in Sweden & demand action over gang rapes

RT News

Hundreds of Malmo residents reportedly gathered on Tuesday to demonstrate against violent gang rapes that have shaken the city in recent weeks. The protestors demanded that the government takes decisive steps to protect women.

Read the full article.

21) JURY ACQUITS FIRST SIX J20 DEFENDANTS, REBUKING GOVERNMENT’S PUSH FOR COLLECTIVE PUNISHMENT

Sam Adler-Bell, The Intercept

On Thursday, a jury acquitted six defendants charged with felonies stemming from their arrests at protests surrounding Donald Trump’s inauguration on January 20. The acquittal is a blow to the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the District of Columbia: a jury rebuke in the first tranche of 194 defendants the government is seeking to collectively punish for the acts of a handful of individuals.

Read the full article.

22) Toronto Const. James Forcillo charged with perjury, attempting to obstruct justice

CBC News

Toronto police Const. James Forcillo, who was convicted of attempted murder in the 2013 shooting death of Sammy Yatim, has been charged with perjury and attempting to obstruct justice.

Read the full article.

23) More than 100 human rights activists killed in Colombia in 2017, UN says

Reuters

More than 100 human rights defenders have been killed in Colombia this year, according to the United Nations, which urged more accountability and better protections.

Read the full article.

24) All I want for Christmas is an end to porn culture sold as empowerment

Meghan Murphy, Feminist Current

In case you were so lucky to have missed it, Love magazine has been unveiling its annual advent calendar throughout the month. And, surprise! We’ve been gifted with a full month of objectification.

Read the full article.

25) $1B class action filed against Loblaws for bread price-fixing

CBC News

A woman from Elliot Lake, Ont. has filed a $1 billion class-action lawsuit against Loblaw Companies Ltd. after the company revealed it participated in industry-wide price-fixing of bread for 14 years.

Read the full article.

26) THE ELECTION FRAUD IN HONDURAS FOLLOWS DECADES OF CORRUPTION FUNDED BY THE U.S. WAR ON DRUGS

Danielle Marie Mackey, The Intercept

On the night of December 2, 2017, a Honduran woman in the rural province of Olancho was protesting what she saw as a stolen election. The woman, eight months pregnant, stood in the streets in violation of a national curfew, and she screamed alongside a rebellious multitude, “Fuera JOH!” (“Out JOH!”), referring to the incumbent president, Juan Orlando Hernández, who many believe fraudulently rigged the elections in his favor to maintain power. The Honduran military and police forces had flooded the streets to enforce the curfew, and the woman was shot in her abdomen, reportedly by a soldier. She was rushed to a nearby clinic where her baby was delivered by emergency cesarean. The child was born with a gunshot wound to the leg.

Read the full article.

27) At Christmas, families on the edge of homelessness must choose: gifts or rent?

Erin McCormick, The Guardian

For those living hand to mouth, the holiday season brings added stress: ‘Every time you get an extra penny, something comes along that costs a nickel more’.

Read the full article.

See also: Roy Moore, Honduras, Site C and more -- The Left Chapter Sunday Reading List December 10 - 17

See also: The #MeToo Movement, Jerusalem, Honduras and more -- The Left Chapter Sunday Reading List December 3 - 10

Sunday, October 30, 2016

Adam Capay, the ONDP, the US Greens & more -- The Left Chapter Sunday Reading List: October 23-30

This week's list of articles and opinion pieces that I see as must reads if you are looking for a roundup that should be of interest to The Left Chapter readers. 

This list covers the week of October 23-October 30. It is in order of date of the article's  release. 



Globe & Mail Editorial Board

Learn the name of Adam Capay. He is the living symbol of everything that is wrong with Canada’s prisons, its justice system and its treatment of indigenous people.



Evan Johnston, Socialist.ca

The Ontario New Democratic Party (ONDP) has nominated former Hamilton Police Association president, Mike Thomas, to be their candidate for the Nov 17 by-election in Niagara West-Glanbrook.
 
Thomas, a retired police officer of 30 years and former President and CEO of the Hamilton Police Association (2010-2014), will be representing the ONDP in the the riding recently vacated by former Progressive Conservative leader Tim Hudak.



Danny Haiphong, Black Agenda Report

I consider myself a Marxist. However, the term "Marxist" is merely a label. Those who ascribe to the tenets of Marxist thought must place their political affiliations within the context of the current historical moment. Anti-communism and imperialist hegemony have set back the struggle for a classless society to the point where much of the US left is mired in confusion as to what political direction should be taken to confront the challenges before us. One of these challenges is the 2016 elections. The radical left should plan on voting Green this November and building a mass movement around the demands put forward by the Jill Stein and Ajamu Baraka campaign.



Jonathan Kay, The Walrus

In 2014, Tasha Kheiriddin, a self-professed “life-long small-c conservative,” announced in a National Post column that she wouldn’t be voting for Tim Hudak’s Tories in the then-upcoming Ontario election. Her reason? The Tory platform would limit state-funded educational options for Zara, her four-year-old daughter, who’d been diagnosed with Asperger’s. The next day, Post editorial-board member Jesse Kline accused Kheiriddin of hypocrisy. “Too many people purport to espouse fiscal conservative values, but make an exception for the issues that affect them personally,” he wrote.



Scott Gilmore, Maclean's 

There is a young First Nations man in Thunder Bay who the province of Ontario has kept in a hole for 52 months. His name is Adam Capay. When he was 19 he was arrested on minor charges and sent to jail. There he got into a fight and another man died. We don’t know if Capay is guilty—he has been waiting an incredible four years for his trial.



Edward Keenan, Toronto Star

On Monday evening, Cedarbrae library near Markham and Lawrence in Scarborough was humming — or whatever the muted librarian-approved equivalent of humming is. It was packed, in any event: the Youth Hub was full of teenagers at the Homework Help table and crowded around the televisions playing video games. The Learning Centre’s rows of desks were filled with people working away on laptops. The study rooms were fully occupied, the work stations lined with people, the computer terminals virtually all in use, the kids book nook area being well put to use. Between the shelves towards the back of the upper floor, where the library houses book collections in 12 languages including Hindi, Tamil and Pashto, a group of high school-aged kids were lounging on the floor, reading, doing homework, chatting.



Ben Spurr, Toronto Star

Advocates for Toronto’s poor are criticizing the city for its lack of action on creating a discounted transit pass for low-income riders, saying that repeated delays to the project are undermining the anti-poverty plan championed by Mayor John Tory.



Rae Story, Morning Star

HOW DO we explain the phenomenon of prostitution? If we believe it to be a form of exploitation, is it better described as gendered or classed?

The feminist position on the sex industry, if not always well understood, is certainly well known to be critical, especially in its most traditional manifestations. But what about a socialist feminist perspective?

After all, the make-up of the sex industry can be most effectively described as the renting of working-class, migrant and poor women, by middle-class or otherwise materially comfortable men.



Nicola Davis, The Guardian

Scientists have managed to reconstruct the route by which HIV/Aids arrived in the US – exonerating once and for all the man long blamed for the ensuing pandemic in the west.



Shaun King, New York Daily News

I’m a huge NBA fan. Wednesday, if you didn’t know it, was the first game of the year for many teams and we are now in that short sports sweet spot with NFL and college football, playoff baseball, and the opening week of NBA action all happening at the same time.

On Wednesday, the Philadelphia 76ers asked a special guest, R&B singer Sevyn Streeter, to sing the “Star-Spangled Banner,” before the game. Not only was she ready, glammed up and well-rehearsed, she even spent time promoting the opening game against the Oklahoma City Thunder on social media. Then, just minutes before she was scheduled to go out onto the court to sing the national anthem, they yanked her because she had a stylish shirt on that simply said “We Matter.”



Arun Gupta, Raw Story

When the Raw Story visited the Bundy bunch inside the Malheur National Wildlife Refuge they were calling for a revolution against the federal government. Rifle-toting supporters said, “ I’m here to fight for freedom and get our Constitution back,” and “I would support this to the death, literally.”

Now eight months after their occupation came to an end the government case has ended in a jury acquitting the two Bundy brothers and five other supporters on all charges but one, including the main one of conspiracy. The government failed to prove the Bundy Bunch “had engaged in an illegal conspiracy that kept federal workers — employees of the Fish and Wildlife Service and the Bureau of Land Management — from doing their jobs.”



Thursday, June 9, 2016

Rejecting the lesser evil -- Why you should not buy into mainstream narratives about voting

As the upstart and surprising Bernie Sanders campaign appears, sadly, to have lost to corporate Democrat Hillary Clinton (who I have noted in the past in anything but a left candidate), the calls for leftists and progressives in the United States to rally around her Presidential candidacy to "stop Trump" are getting louder and louder.

As a Canadian, of course, my rallying to her cause would be of little importance even were I so inclined - which I am not - but even here in this country one finds people calling for a sort of moral endorsement anyway presumably as our good vibes or something will somehow help to get some of our reluctant leftist neighbours on board.

But the American Presidential election aside, Canadians are more than familiar with the "strategic voting" and "lesser-of-evils" arguments as they have polluted our politics on all levels of government for decades. Arguments around the necessity of voting -- and of voting for a party or candidate who, moreover, can supposedly "win" -- have been used by countless candidates for or advocates of the Liberal Party and, to a lesser but still very significant degree, the NDP.

Every election leftists are told that the "danger" of the election or re-election of (insert the name of the threat here) to our democracy, society, polity, people, etc., is so great that there is "no choice" but to hold one's nose and do the adult or socially responsible thing and go vote. Even if you are voting for something or someone you do not believe in.

Every election we are met with same sterile, empty arguments to defend these exhortations to the ballot box.

I think it is time we look at some of these arguments for "lesser-of-evil" voting -- or voting at all -- more closely for what they are worth. Which is nothing much.

1) If you vote for a "fringe" candidate or a candidate who "cannot win" you are wasting your precious vote!

The grandparent of all of these arguments is this one. We will return to the question of the morality and undemocratic aspect of telling people that voting for what they believe in is wrong, while voting for something they do not really believe in is somehow right, but even on a technical level this specific argument is in many cases actually quite absurd.

This is due to the way our electoral systems work and the uneven distributions of support parties or candidates have across various geographical boundaries.

Simply put, in many areas the "lesser-of-evil" candidate or party either cannot win or, alternately, is basically guaranteed to win.

For example, if you are in a state, say Texas, where in the coming election Trump ends up 20 points ahead in the lead-up to voting day, you are no more "throwing away" your vote by voting for Green Party leader Jill Stein than you are by voting for Hillary Clinton.

The reverse is equally true. In a state where Clinton leads by a significant margin there is no "tactical" need to vote for her even if one thinks that necessary where it matters.

In the Canadian system, there are ultimately always only a small number of ridings that actually end up being a real battle where a "lesser-of-evil" candidate can truly knock out an "evil" one, in our case presumably the Conservative. Most ridings -- in fact far more than you might commonly think -- in a national election (and many provincial ones) will be ridings where a Conservative, Liberal or New Democrat is virtually certain to win, or where the race is between the Liberals and NDP and the Conservatives have no chance.

In none of these ridings or states does the "wasted vote" argument stand up at all. By not voting or by voting with your "heart" you will not effect the outcome in anyway. In fact, in some cases, as in many Canadian ridings in the last federal election, voting "strategically" can even lead to bizarre outcomes such as the defeat of NDP incumbents to help "Stop Harper"!

In  other words, people are being most often called upon to sacrifice principles and beliefs in many cases when this will make absolutely no difference whatsoever other than to (a point to which we will return) give your endorsement to a candidate that you did not want.

But what of those minority of cases where a small number of votes might actually (and not just rhetorically) make the difference?

We will get back to those shortly.

2) If you don't vote or "waste your vote" your voice is not heard/does not matter/you have "no right to complain"

From a leftist perspective this is a particularly bizarre argument to have leveled at you for one very simple reason -- our voice is already being left out, does not matter and is not being heard!

And this is also why you certainly do have every right to complain whether you want to vote or not.

People such as myself basically have no say already in that none of these parties or candidates who can "win" represent our views. For people living in poverty, the working-class, and racialized and marginalized communities it is not at all apparent to me how their "voice" will be heard by voting for parties who often barely or simply tokenistically claim to represent or fight for their interests and who, once in power, generally act directly against these interests.

And, ironically, it is these very arguments we are confronting here that we hear election-after-election-after-election-after-election that keep ensuring that we have no voice. They do so as, if we always end up voting and working for these "lesser-of-evil" parties and candidates we are directly preventing the emergence of alternatives that would be worth supporting and that, one day at least, might win or effect change.

As to the claim that if you do not vote "you cannot complain", I think it is time to turn that rhetorical flourish on its head.

If you keep showing up to vote for one or another flavour of the same bullshit, if you cast a ballot endorsing parties or candidates you fundamentally disagree with or who act in ways inimical to your interests, why, by enabling this, should you have anymore right to complain?

Your participation and vote acts as a reinforcement to whatever you back and to the process as a whole as does implying that it is a necessary act.

Given that you directly are participating in creating the mess in the first place, how is this somehow more morally praiseworthy than those who by rejecting voting or rejecting voting for the "lesser-of-evil" refused to do this?

3) Not voting "undermines democracy"

Apparently, for some, democracy is about the act of voting, which is a convenient liberal idea.

Democracy, of course, is about far more than that and withdrawing one's vote or participation in the mainstream narrative is a completely democratic act.

What is increasingly inimical to democracy is the narrowing of the discourse and the political options over the era of neo-liberalism. The major parties in Canada and the United States, including the once social democratic NDP, now only differ from each other on economic issues by a small degree. On foreign policy issues this is also true.

This does not mean the parties are the same. They are not at all. On important issues like criminal justice, abortion, LGBT rights and others there are real divergences that do matter, as these issues matter.

What it does mean, however, is that when it comes to basic issues around inequality, economic injustice,  poverty, the power of corporations and the fundamental nature of capitalism itself, the parties offer up "solutions" and "alternatives" that are all framed within the ideological construct of neo-liberalism and its handmaiden austerity.

Even minor attempts to break this mold -- such as the Liberal stimulus plan in Canada right now -- only do so in a very limited way that does not challenge the underpinnings of austerity itself in that they do not reverse the essential trends in taxation, privatization or social spending that led us to where we are today. They also persist in framing their "stimulus" as temporary and in lauding a return to the "normal" fiscal regime and constraints as the ultimate goal.

Part of what made Bernie Sanders' campaign so exciting for many, in spite of its flaws, was that he is the only major political figure in North America in a generation who pushed back against this, and out of nowhere this electrified millions of Americans who felt disenfranchised and forgotten by Wall St. Democrats like Clinton.

The narrowing of the possible, as when Hillary Clinton ludicrously portrays universal health care -- something that has been achieved in every other advanced developed nation in the world other than the United States -- as somehow an Utopian and unrealistic goal, is the real and actual undermining of what is left of our democracy.

And it is part of the reason people do not bother to "show up".

That they do not necessarily articulate their indifference to the process in political terms does not mean it is not a political action. Only elitists think that political acts are always accompanied by a manifesto of some type.

If we want to expand democracy, we need to reject rather than embrace a mainstream politics that is anything but democratic in the possibilities it allows, the choices it offers and the access to power it grants.

How is voting for something you do not actually believe in or want "democratic"?

4) But what about Trump?

"Do you want Trump to win?"

Get used to hearing this facile cry should you dare to suggest you might stay home or vote for a real left-wing candidate like Jill Stein in the US.

We have heard this one before of course. Many times. Whether Harper or Bush or countless other examples from Rob Ford in Toronto to whomever. And it sounds convincing.

The logic is that if you "throw away" your vote or do not vote this is de facto the same as voting for whatever evil person it is that you should be voting for someone like Clinton or Trudeau to oppose.

The problem with the logic lies in what I call the Ralph Nader fallacy. The totally false contention, spouted by countless liberals and Democrats everywhere, that it was Ralph Nader who lost the election for Al Gore in 2000 thereby allowing George Bush to come to power and enabling all the "evil" that flowed out of that.

But it is not true. Al Gore lost because of Al Gore. He lost because he could not persuade those who voted for Nader to vote for him and he could not persuade tens-of-millions who stayed home to bother. He lost because he was so uninspiring he could not even carry his own home state of Tennessee which he lost by a far wider margin than can be explained by Nader's vote there, and that would have given him the Presidency.

In fact, in only two states did Nader have a percentage of the vote that might have made a difference. Florida and New Hampshire. New Hampshire going to Gore would not have effected the result. Gore winning Florida, of course, would have.

But in the end Gore lost Florida, as we all know, due to the actions of the Supreme Court.

In every other state in the US voting for Nader had no impact on the ultimate result at all. It is hard for me to accept the notion that Nader is responsible for the decisions of the US Supreme Court.

Far more absurd is the presumption that those who voted for Nader would have either voted or would have all voted for Gore and thereby handed him the election. That is simply that. A presumption.

It is good propaganda but also fundamentally total bullshit.

The slightly over 1% of the voters in Florida who voted for Nader did not "elect" Bush or play spoilers. They simply did not feel it was worth voting for Gore.

This one and rather exceptional example, that is rendered facetious by the many other states that Gore could have won but did not and that had nothing to do with Nader, has been used to browbeat and terrify progressive and left voters in both the United States and Canada ever since.

But its presumptions are not its only flaw.

So are its more aggressive assertions. Which are, in this case, that Nader voters should be held accountable for the actions and consequences of the Bush Presidency despite having voted for someone else.

This may have seemed compelling in the wake of the war in Iraq, but it seems far less compelling after the bloody, imperialist, drone-loving administration of "progressive" Obama that has achieved relatively little domestically and that has rained down death internationally.

Obama's Secretary of State was, of course, Hillary Clinton and she is an unrepentant imperialist and military hawk. She supported, enabled and directly participated in the decisions that led to things like the bloody coup in Honduras. She is a stalwart supporter of Israel and supported grotesque initiatives like the lowering of the minimum wage in Haiti and now the imperialist austerity assault on Puerto Rico.

As I have outlined in the past, there is simply no leftist case for supporting Clinton for the Presidency other than that she is "better" than Donald Trump.

While this may be true, this does not absolve those who vote for and support Clinton of their direct responsibility of what she then does as President. Not indirect, not by allegedly "allowing" someone to win, but by actually having voted for the person who then does what they do.

If Nader voters are allegedly culpable for the actions of Bush, how much more so are Obama voters for the actions of Obama who they actually voted for? If you are going to try to force those on the left who choose not to support a candidate like Gore or Clinton to own the actions (or presumed actions in the case of Trump) of those they were or could be defeated by, then you had better own the actions of those who you are supporting with your vote.

You had better own the austerity, pandering to Wall St., false narratives, dubious past record, violent imperialism, drone strike murders, killing of Honduran activists, lack of real progress and much more that you enabled by voting for it!

That blood and viciousness is actually on your hands, all cries of  supposedly having to be "realistic" aside.

It may be that Trump represents a "once in a generation" threat that makes a more compelling case for a "tactical" vote, though I do not agree with that. Even if one does, as Seattle Socialist Kshama Sawant pointed out in her appeal to Sanders to eschew the Democratic Party, "If electing a Republican is really Bernie’s main concern, there is no reason he could not at least run in the 40+ states where it’s absolutely clear the Democratic or Republican candidate will win, while not putting his name on the 5-10 closely contested “swing states.”"

The same is true of the rest of us.

Do not make voting for a terrible reactionary like Hillary Clinton, for a farce like Trudeau or a sham like the NDP some great example of or pretense of virtue. Nor the act of voting itself for that matter.

In the end, most often, the supposedly tactical vote is the crutch we fall back on to explain why we did not do more to create something we should vote for. And this is why the mainstream narratives about voting are not just a dead end for the left but will reinforce our irrelevance and culture of defeat.

See also: There is no socialist case for supporting Hillary Clinton

See also: Rejecting a Mulcair or electing a Sanders or a Corbyn is not enough