Monday, July 4, 2016

Black Lives Matter is right -- The police are the oppressor

You know, it is always appalling to see some oblivious white idiot walking around with the horrifically racist Cleveland Indians logo on their chest or on some sign of some kind.

I did not see this specific idiot in the picture, but saw another entitled white idiot, strolling down the platform of the Go Station after a Jays-Indians game this year with this disgraceful caricature on the front of her jersey.

Had one approached her, called her out on the bigotry implicit in wearing such an image, she would no doubt have been both shocked and denied it was bigoted or racist at all. It was "tradition" or simply a logo or just for a laugh or whatever pretense one uses to justify this form of abject, vicious ugliness that can only be ok to those who simply are unwilling to understand what images like these mean historically and the role they have played in creating a culture of racist indifference.

The vast bulk of white folks it seems simply do not want to and cannot accept that they have built and are the direct beneficiaries of a colonialist and racist social order and that they have woven that order's narratives and lies into their fictions about themselves and their society,

And so it is with the pathetic and, indeed, deeply racist reactions to the very minor, and profoundly just, protest that Toronto's Black Lives Matter (BLM) made at the Toronto Pride parade.

Suddenly legions of white people, the vast majority of whom could not possibly care less about LGBT pride or liberation aside from when they get to sound liberal about gay marriage with their friends, are up in arms about how BLM allegedly sought to derail Pride for their own "agenda" or sought to somehow "exclude" the police in future as if such a thing were possible,

Accused plagiarist and pseudo-intellectual dilettante Margaret Wente, who always seems to play the apologist for power and the status quo in situations like this, wrote a column, of course, furious that BLM's protest might imply that we have issues of systemic racism in our policing in Canada comparable to those in the United States -- which, needless to say in spite of all the evidence to the contrary, we don't because this clueless wealthy white person says we don't.

Very convincing.

To her, these activists from a community that has been marginalized economically and socially for centuries are "bullies" -- as opposed to the police whose practices of carding and racial profiling have been an assault on the rights of people she does not know or care about, and whose continued resistance to changing their behaviour belies their rhetoric about celebrating inclusivity.

The most powerful people in our society, one of the armed wings of the state, are supposedly being "bullied" by unarmed, peaceful activists from a community they have brutalized forever.  It is a stunning, staggering, shocking reversal of historical fact,

Or we have Joe Warmington, who was a stalwart apologist for homophobic bigot Rob Ford, claiming that Pride owes the police an apology! Maybe he could apologize to Toronto's LGBT community first out of basic decency.


That is what so many of us white folks are, Pathetic.

We are people who will walk down a street proudly displaying "Chief Wahoo" even though we know what colonialist racism and violence did to the native and indigenous peoples of North America and even though we know what it continues to do today. Too many of us simply do not care.

In fact, when called on it, white people love to play the victim and to try to cry "reverse racism" or some other sad refrain.

And so it is again, now, in Toronto.

BLM peacefully, and for a very short time, stopped a march that was created in the wake of police violence to call out not just issues with Pride but continuing police violence against racialized communities. BLM forced Pride organizers to take notice in the only way they could and forced concessions that now appear will not be honoured.

In doing so, they acted in the very best traditions of Pride.

And yet the braying of reaction, so utterly predictable, again tries to make the oppressed the oppressor and the victimized the victimizers.

As Malcolm X said ".If you're not careful, the newspapers will have you hating the people who are being oppressed, and loving the people who are doing the oppressing.”

And that is what we need to remember.

It is the police who are doing the oppressing and it is Black Lives Matter that is fighting oppression.

Not only are Black Lives Matter right to ask that the police not have a float in Pride, the police should never have been there to begin with.

See also: It is not "political correctness" that hurts the poor Mr. Kay, it is systemic oppression and those who enable it

See also: It is not just the police spending in Toronto that is out of control -- it is the police themselves


  1. Nice, conflating the Cleveland Indians logo with with stopping a parade they were invited to, painting it as racist and extorting "concessions" before allowing it to go on. That was forcing Pride organizers to take notice "in the only way they could."

    1. When white people are willing to undertake a life ''Black like Me'' for 6 months, then and only then should their faux ''River of White Tears'' be heard. Until then, have a damn seat

    2. Timbits has a point. The sit in did more harm than good. Antagonizing people is a poor way to get them on to your side. Change never happens quickly. The only thing people do quickly is get angry.

  2. Great post Michael Thanks

  3. BLM have no right to demand Canadians pay in anyway for USA's history. Ignorant of history is what they are. MY history is FN & EU (1665) and MY own Tribes took 'slaves' from wars with other Tribes here. It's in our history books - my EU side's names are there with their non-named FN wives. All this has done is make hard feelings, UN-necessarily, all way around. Everyone experiences bigotry against them in life - get over it instead of wallowing in the past. BLM is militant and an enemy of me & mine now! THEY simply base THEIR hatred upon skin color - sickening anyone accepts this.