This week's list of articles, news items and opinion pieces that I see as must reads if you are looking for a roundup that should be of interest to The Left Chapter readers.
This list covers the week of June 17 - 24. It is generally in order of the date of the article's release.
There are two articles from prior to the period that have been included. They have been integrated into the post.
1) Human rights groups condemn Ukraine over its funding of nazi militias
The Morning Star
HUMAN rights groups in Ukraine hit out today after it was revealed that nazi militias involved in brutal and violent attacks against minorities have received cash from the government.
Read the full article.
2) Et Tu, Bernie?
Chris Hedges, TruthDig
There are two versions of Bernie Sanders. There is the old Bernie Sanders, who mounted a quixotic campaign for the Democratic presidential nomination as a democratic socialist who refused corporate cash and excoriated corporate Democrats. And there is the new Bernie Sanders, who dutifully plays by the party’s rules, courts billionaires, refused to speak out in support of the lawsuit brought against the Democratic National Committee (DNC) for rigging the primaries against him and endorses Democratic candidates who espouse the economic and political positions he once denounced.
Read the full article.
3) Report looks at child poverty across Canada
Jordan Press, The Canadian Press
Anti-poverty groups are raising the stakes on the Liberal government's promise to reduce the prevalence of low-income families by detailing child poverty rates in all 338 federal ridings -- including the above-average rates facing constituents of Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and Finance Minister Bill Morneau.
Read the full article.
4) Colombian Far-Right Candidate Duque Wins Presidential Elections
Telesur
One hour after the polls closed on Sunday for the second round of Colombian presidential elections, electoral authorities announced that far-right candidate Ivan Duque won over the leftist alternative Gustavo Petro with 53,98 percent versus 41,81 percent as 100 percent of the vote was counted.
Read the full article.
5) Colombia: FARC Willing to Meet With Duque to Maintain Peace
Telesur
The Common Alternative Revolutionary Force, the FARC, is worried that Duque's victory could hurt the historic peace process.
Read the full article.
6) Colombia: Duque Torpedoes Peace Before Taking Office
Telesur
Colombia’s Senate has heeded a call from Ivan Duque to indefinitely postpone a bill on the procedures to apply the Special Jurisdiction for Peace.
Read the full article.
7) The Democrats’ Myopic Reaction to the Trump–Kim Summit
James Careden, The Nation
In his recent Nation report from the Singapore summit, the redoubtable Tim Shorrock observed, “Even as the first images flashed across the world of Trump and Kim shaking hands against the unusual background of US and DPRK flags flapping together, social media and op-ed sections of media sites were filled with denunciations of Trump. Democratic leaders in the House and Senate led the attack.”
Read the full article.
8) Ontario Looks Right
Herman Rosenfeld, Jacobin
Canada is not immune to the rise of right-wing populism. Case in point: the recent election of Doug Ford as Premier of Ontario after years of Liberal rule.
Read the full article.
9) Chimps and orangutans among species in danger of being wiped out in imminent mass extinction of primates, scientists warn
Josh Gabbatiss, The Independent
Primate species including chimpanzees and orangutans are on the brink of extinction, and scientists fear that without a concerted global effort they will soon be gone for good.
Read the full article.
10) The unspeakable cruelty of Trump’s child-migrant camps
Sarah Kendzior, The Globe and Mail
Under the direction of Donald Trump and Attorney-General Jeff Sessions, the U.S. government has snatched roughly 2,000 children of asylum seekers from their parents – including an infant girl who was taken from her wailing mother while breastfeeding – and put them in detention camps. They are there for the crime of existing, as migrant children fleeing foreign violence and oppression, in Mr. Trump’s United States.
Read the full article.
11) Canada detains migrant kids, too, and it needs to stop, experts say
David P. Ball, The Toronto Star
Immigration experts and government critics say Canada Border Services Agency’s ongoing detention of minors — generally with their families — is deeply damaging to child welfare and mental health.
Read the full article.
12) THE U.S. HAS TAKEN MORE THAN 3,700 CHILDREN FROM THEIR PARENTS — AND HAS NO PLAN FOR RETURNING THEM
Ryan Devereaux, The Intercept
THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION’S program of systematically separating migrant children from their parents is steadily expanding, government officials confirmed Tuesday. Under Attorney General Jeff Sessions’s “zero tolerance” doctrine, U.S. authorities have been ordered to criminally prosecute all individuals arrested for illegally crossing the border without exception, including asylum-seekers and parents arriving with small children.
Read the full article.
13) Trump’s new immigration cruelty
Barry Sheppard, Red Flag
Washington has a long history of using deportations to strike fear among undocumented workers. In recent years deportations have increased – former president Barack Obama became known as “deporter in chief”.
Read the full article.
14) Canada aims to avoid detaining migrant children, but it happens
Benjamin Shingler · CBC News
McGill study on Canadian practice finds 'psychiatric and academic difficulties long after detention'
Read the full article.
15) If Justin Trudeau really cares about keeping refugee women and girls alive, his government needs to rescind the Safe Third Country Agreement
Jaymie Heilman and Maria Walker, Feminist Current
Many Canadians are rightly horrified by the Trump administration’s recent move to begin separating children from their asylum-seeking parents when they cross the US-Mexico border. A related — and perhaps equally devastating — change to American policy has received far less attention: domestic violence and gang violence no longer qualify as grounds for asylum in the US. Because the Canadian government still adheres to the Safe Third Country Agreement with the US, Canada is complicit with a policy that could sentence tens of thousands of Central American refugee women to extreme physical abuse, sexual enslavement, and death.
Read the full article.
16) The Trump administration is keeping preschool children in “tender age” detention centers
David Gilbert, Vice News
The Trump administration is forcibly separating babies and toddlers from their parents on the border with Mexico and sending them to what they call “tender age shelters” in South Texas, according to a report from the Associated Press.
Read the full article.
17) Trump Signs Executive Order To Stop Family Separation At Border
Roberta Rampton, Reuters
U.S. President Donald Trump backed down on Wednesday on an immigration policy that sparked outrage at home and abroad, signing an executive order to end the separation of children from their parents when immigrant families are caught crossing the U.S.-Mexico border illegally.
Read the full article.
18) Migrant Children Drugged Without Consent At Government Centers, Court Documents Show
Roque Planas, HuffPost US
Staff working on the behalf of the Office of Refugee Resettlement are routinely drugging detained child migrants with psychotropics without their parents’ consent, according to legal filings.
Read the full article.
19) Ripping Children Away From Families Is As American As Apple Pie
Ricky Riley, Blavity
America has a long history of separating children from their families.
Read the full article.
20) Immigrant children beaten, stripped, placed in solitary confinement at U.S. detention centre: Court documents
Michael Biesecker, Jake Pearson and Garance Burke, The Associated Press
Immigrant children as young as 14 housed at a juvenile detention centre in Virginia say they were beaten while handcuffed and locked up for long periods in solitary confinement, left nude and shivering in concrete cells.
Read the full article.
21) Dear America, we can teach you about cruelty to refugees. Love, Australia
Brigid Delaney, The Guardian
Yes, America, we have so much to teach you about cruelty and brutality and violence to some of the most vulnerable people on earth. We are a small nation, but on this issue we really punch above our weight!
Read the full article.
22) Think your ancestors came here legally and 'waited their turn'? Think again
Sheila Langan, Irish Central
As happens every time policies and practices against undocumented immigrants dominate the news, this week a vast array of memes and messages have been circulating from Americans who believe that their immigrant ancestors have nothing in common with today's undocumented immigrants.
Read the full article.
23) AN ABUSED WOMAN CAME TO THE U.S. SEEKING ASYLUM. THE GOVERNMENT TOOK HER 5-YEAR-OLD SON. THIS IS HOW SHE GOT HIM BACK.
Debbie Nathan, The Intercept
A GUATEMALAN WOMAN whose child was taken from her last month by immigration authorities in Texas after coming to the U.S. seeking asylum was released after 38 days in detention last week. Immediately after being freed, she went to the federally funded facility that was managing her 5-year-old son’s care and recovered him.
Read the full article.
24) Brazil's Lula da Silva: 'This is Political Imprisonment'
Telesur
In an exclusive interview, Brazil's favorite presidential candidate, Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva, says he'd never betray the trust of his supporters.
Read the full article.
25) Should Canada give up on NAFTA? Yes.
Gordon Laxer, The Toronto Star
NAFTA is a corporate rights agreement, not a free-trade agreement in the original sense.
Read the full article.
26) Australian war crimes
Ben Hillier, Red Flag
How many civilians have Australian special forces killed in Afghanistan? We don’t know and may never know. But it is becoming clearer that war crimes of a scale not previously reported or acknowledged have been carried out by some in Australia’s most venerated military units.
Read the full article.
27) Italy's far-right government announces 'census' and deportations of Roma traveller population
Jon Stone, The Independent
Italy’s new far-right interior minister has announced a “census” of the country’s Roma community and set the stage for deportations of the ethnic group.
Read the full article.
28) Italy's deputy PM Salvini called for 'mass cleansing, street by street, quarter by quarter', newly resurfaced footage reveals
Tom Embury-Dennis, The Guardian
Footage has re-emerged of Italy’s new interior minister calling for a “mass cleansing” of migrants from “entire parts” of the country.
Read the full article.
29) Salvini’s ‘Roma register’ marks a dangerous step towards fascism
The Morning Star
ITALIAN Interior Minister Matteo Salvini’s order that all Roma people in the country be registered so that “non-Italians” among them can be expelled looks like fascism.
Read the full article.
30) 'Commie cadet' who wore Che Guevara T-shirt kicked out of US army
The Associated Press
A West Point cadet who wore a Che Guevara T-shirt to his graduation and posted a message online saying “communism will win” has been discharged from the US army.
Read the full article.
31) Canada's Chrystia Freeland 'Blind To Emerging Multipolar World'
Nino Pagliccia, Telesur
In a strange case of reversed roles, Canadian Minister of Foreign Affairs Chrystia Freeland tried to convince U.S. President Donald Trump to return to his lost path of globalization and international trade agreements in an impassioned speech she gave at the Foreign Policy Forum on June 13 in Washington, D.C.
Read the full article.
32) Jewish extremists taunt ‘Ali’s on the grill’ at slain toddler’s relatives
Jacob Magid, The Times of Israel
Two dozen far-right protesters shout outside courtroom in support of Duma terror attack perpetrators; relatives slam police for letting abusive chorus continue unabated.
Read the full article.
33) A Brief History of U.S. Intervention in the Countries of Origin of Central American Asylum Seekers
Mark Tseng-Putterman, Medium
At the margins of the mainstream discursive stalemate over immigration lies over a century of historical U.S. intervention that politicians and pundits on both sides of the aisle seem determined to silence. Since Theodore Roosevelt in 1904 declared the U.S.’s right to exercise an “international police power” in Latin America, the U.S. has cut deep wounds and left deeper scars throughout the region. These wounds are inextricable from the contemporary crisis of internal and international displacement and migration in the region.
Read the full article.
34) Hungary law bans helping migrants
BBC News
The Hungarian parliament has passed new legislation that criminalises lawyers and activists who help asylum seekers.
Read the full article.
35) 'Disgusting': 72% of Alberta inmates haven't been convicted of crimes — the highest proportion in Canada
Jonny Wakefield, The Edmonton Journal
Seven out of every 10 people behind bars in Alberta haven’t been convicted of their alleged crime, a statistic the head of a local prisoner advocacy group called “disgusting.”
Read the full article.
36) Three Tulsa schools don’t want to commemorate America’s racist past anymore
Christianna Silva, Vice News
Three schools in Tulsa decided to change their names from honoring a slave owner, a Confederate general, and Christopher Columbus to instead highlight positive reflections of America’s past.
Read the full article.
37) Anti-fascist lessons from Republican Spain
Jim Jump, The Morning Star
As the 80th anniversary of the decisive Spanish civil war battle of Ebro approaches, JIM JUMP recalls the heroism of the International Brigade and how European governments aided and abetted the victory of fascism.
Read the full article.
38) Jagmeet Singh Says NDP Won’t Bail On Canada-Israel Group, Despite Pressure
Althia Raj, The Huffington Post
The federal NDP says it has no plans to withdraw from the Canada-Israel interparliamentary group despite vocal concerns from some of its party members.
Read the full article.
Please note that this was in response to the Open Letter: A call for the NDP to withdraw from the Canada-Israel Interparliamentary Group that was published on The Left Chapter among other forums.
39) Overrepresentation of Indigenous people in Canada’s prisons persists amid drop in overall incarceration
Emma McIntosh and Alex McKeen, The Toronto Star
The population of people behind bars in Canada, overall on the decline, continues to include a massive overrepresentation of Indigenous inmates, according to newly released government data.
Read the full article.
40) As 'Wealthiest and Freest Country in the World,' Nikki Haley Tells Bernie Sanders It's 'Ridiculous' to Examine US Poverty
Jake Johnson, Common Dreams
"As it happens, I personally believe that it is totally appropriate for the U.N. Special Rapporteur to focus on poverty in the United States," Sanders responded.
Read the full article.
41) Children's teeth are paying the price for the cancellation of fluoridation in Calgary
June Dabbagh, Leagh Harfield, Wendy Street-Wadey and Juliet Guichon, The Calgary Herald
As the school year draws to an end, it is time to consider how Calgary has been treating its children lately. In one respect, the answer is not well at all.
Read the full article.
42) CANADIAN DELEGATES ATTEND MARX CONFERENCE IN CHINA
Elizabeth Rowley, People's Voice
In late May, the Communist Party of China invited other Communist, workers’ and left parties from around the world to an important event marking the 200th anniversary of the birth of Karl Marx. About 70 delegates from 50 parties attended a theoretical conference held on May 29 in the southern city of Shenzhen, on “The Historical Contribution of Karl Marx and the Contemporary Significance of Marxism.”
Read the full article.
43) Fraser Institute Bombards Ontario With Ads Falsely Portraying Minimum Wage Workers as Teenagers
Press Progress
As Premier-designate Doug Ford prepares to roll back Ontario’s minimum wage, the Fraser Institute is blanketing social media with misleading ads that falsely portray minimum wage workers as teenagers.
Read the full article.
44) Extreme Inequality Creates Global Disorder
James K. Galbraith, The Nation
The principal driver of global inequality—both within and between countries—is the global financial regime. This has been a feature since the end of the Bretton Woods system in 1971, with recurrent catastrophic effects following the onset of the 1980s debt crisis, including the collapse of the socialist nations and the 1997 Asian financial crisis. Back then, it was a conservative stroke of genius to institutionalize “market exchange rates” on a global scale. Those markets work well enough for rich nations, but they guarantee problems for everyone else. Each exchange crisis has wiped out a decade or more of progress against inequality, as anyone in Brazil, Argentina, Mexico, or much of Africa will tell you. The rise of China, on the other hand, has everything to do with its refusal to play the game of open capital markets. And while inequality in China rose rapidly for internal reasons beginning in the 1990s, it stabilized more than a decade ago.
Read the full article.
45) Trump flips on North Korea, declaring country still an 'extraordinary threat'
The Guardian
Donald Trump has declared that North Korea still poses an “extraordinary threat” to the United States, just days after saying that the country’s nuclear program no longer constituted a danger.
Read the full article.
46) Why Canadians Don’t Care About the Air India Bombing
Chandrima Chakraborty, The Tyee
I have no personal connection to the tragedy, but our country’s broad indifference to it came to me as a surprise. A course I was teaching at McMaster University in Hamilton, Ont., 25 years or more after the bombing, called for a section on Air India Flight 182, but when I went to look up the scholarly research, I was astonished by how little there was.
Read the full article.
47) The age of patriarchy: how an unfashionable idea became a rallying cry for feminism today
Charlotte Higgins, The Guardian
On 7 January this year, the alt-right insurgent Steve Bannon turned on his TV in Washington DC to watch the Golden Globes. The mood of the event was sombre. It was the immediate aftermath of multiple accusations of rape and sexual assault against film producer Harvey Weinstein, which he has denied. The women, whose outfits would normally have been elaborate and the subject of frantic scrutiny, wore plain and sober black. In the course of a passionate speech, Oprah Winfrey told the audience that “brutally powerful men” had “broken” something in the culture. These men had caused women to suffer: not only actors, but domestic workers, factory workers, agricultural workers, athletes, soldiers and academics. The fight against this broken culture, she said, transcended “geography, race, religion, politics and workplace”.
Read the full article.
48) Canadian winemaker Norman Hardie accused of sexual misconduct
Ann Hui and Ivy Knight, The Globe and Mail
A Globe and Mail investigation reveals a wide-ranging pattern of alleged sexual advances and sexual harassment by Hardie, a major player in Canada’s food and wine industry.
Read the full article.
49) Eurydice Dixon: how one woman’s death put focus on ‘male rage’ in Australia
Gay Alcorn, The Guardian
The alleged rape and murder of a comedian has sparked anger about attitudes to women.
Read the full article.
50) 'Not as ironic as I imagined': the incels spokesman on why he is renouncing them
Justin Ling, The Guardian
In the wake of the Toronto van murders, Jack Peterson was the most prominent defender of the anti-feminist ‘incels’ – until the community turned on him.
Read the full article.
51) Trump’s Military Drops a Bomb Every 12 Minutes, and No One Is Talking About It
Lee Camp, TruthDig
We live in a state of perpetual war, and we never feel it. While you get your gelato at the hip place where they put those cute little mint leaves on the side, someone is being bombed in your name. While you argue with the 17-year-old at the movie theater who gave you a small popcorn when you paid for a large, someone is being obliterated in your name. While we sleep and eat and make love and shield our eyes on a sunny day, someone’s home, family, life and body are being blown into a thousand pieces in our names.
Read the full article.
52) 'We Don't Know... How Bad It Is': 31-Car Oil Train Derails Into Iowa Floodwaters
Jessica Corbett, Common Dreams
Adding to the mountain of evidence that "oil trains are a disaster for our health, our safety, and our climate"—an argument environmentalists have been making for years—a 31-car freight train derailed in Iowa and started leaking crude oil into floodwaters on Friday morning, forcing evacuations of nearby homes and raising concerns about drinking water contamination.
Read the full article.
See also: Border Separations, North Korea Summit, NAFTA & more -- The Left Chapter Sunday Reading List June 10 - 17
The Left Chapter has moved!
The Left Chapter has moved to a new domain.
You can visit us for all our new content at: https://www.theleftchapter.com/
Showing posts with label Calgary. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Calgary. Show all posts
Sunday, June 24, 2018
Border Detentions, Duque Wins in Colombia, Roma Under Threat in Italy & more -- The Left Chapter Sunday Reading List June 17 - 24
Labels:
Australia,
Bernie Sanders,
Brazil,
Calgary,
climate change,
Colombia,
Donald Trump,
Doug Ford,
Hungary,
Israel,
Italy,
Ivan Duque,
Jagmeet Singh,
minimum wage,
NDP,
North Korea,
Ukraine
Saturday, April 1, 2017
Chrystia Freeland, the NDP Leadership Race & more -- February and March on The Left Chapter in review
February and March saw 45 posts published on The Left Chapter. In terms of hits this period saw the highest number, again, for any two month period in our history. This is the fifth consecutive two month period to set a record!
Thanks very much to all our readers and contributors.
Many of the posts related to the NDP's leadership race either made this list or came very, very close. The Left Chapter is actively seeking different perspectives on the race including from supporters of the various candidates. If you are interested, see the end of this post for details on submitting a piece.
Without any further ado the top six posts from the two months, in terms of hits, are:
1) Liberal Minister Chrystia Freeland should resign for celebrating her grandfather's Nazi past
The sins of the mother or father, grandmother or grandfather, should never be held against the child...unless they then appear to lie about and celebrate those sins.
Read More!
2) Niki Ashton is the leader the NDP and Canada needs
Guest Editorial by Robert McCarthy
My name is Robert McCarthy from Sudbury, Ontario and I am supporting Niki Ashton to become the next leader of the New Democratic Party of Canada. Like myself, Niki is a proud Democratic Socialist. She is the candidate that I most identify with. Her vision includes free tuition and student debt forgiveness, opposing pipelines where they infringe on Indigenous rights and endanger the environment, and the expansion of public healthcare to include dental care, pharmacare and access to mental health services for all Canadians. These policies are perfectly in line with what I believe.
Read More!
3) We don't need a populist left, post-identity politics left or 'alt left' to fight the rise of the far right, we just need a left
Have you heard the news?
The "left" is "out of touch" with the pulse of what is going on in the United States and North America more broadly because insert left academic or commentator/insert left publication says this must be true due to Trump's victory in the US Presidential race.
Read More!
4) Sid Ryan hits all the right leftist notes in a powerful video that leaves us asking why he is not running
Sid Ryan, the seemingly divisive former leader of the Ontario Federation of Labour (OFL), has been flirting with the idea of running for the leadership of the NDP for a few months now.
Read More!
5) University of Calgary Conservatives plan to mark International Women's Day with a men's rights movie
The University of Calgary Conservative Party club has decided to team up with the campus Wildrose Party club to honour International Women's Day...by screening a movie praising the noxious anti-feminist Men's Rights extremist movement.
Seriously.
Read More!
6) The backlash against Niki Ashton from anti-Black Lives Matter commentators is what is really off base
Are people really attacking Niki Ashton for taking down a meme due to an objection from Black Lives Matter Vancouver? Apparently, in yet another example of misplaced and wasted outrage serving a right-wing narrative about the chimera of "political correctness", they are!
Read More!
The top food related post for the period was Homestyle Pork Chops in Onion Gravy
Over the coming weeks The Left Chapter is interested in getting different perspectives on the NDP leadership race including from those both inside and outside of the party, from partisans of various candidates (perhaps explaining why), from critics of the race or those who think supporting any of them is perhaps a mistake, from those who would like to see a candidate who has yet to emerge, analysis of the candidates from an objective left perspective, etc.
If you have perspectives about the NDP leadership race specifically that you would like to share in blog/article/editorial form please contact us via theleftchapter@outlook.com
Do you have a left point-of-view or opinion, event or petition, a recipe or a story you want to share?
Send them to The Left Chapter via theleftchapter@outlook.com!
See also: CAFE, Molson Coors Boycott, Road Tolls & more -- December and January on The Left Chapter in review
See also: Canadian Labour, Trump, McMaster & more -- October and November on The Left Chapter in review
Thanks very much to all our readers and contributors.
Many of the posts related to the NDP's leadership race either made this list or came very, very close. The Left Chapter is actively seeking different perspectives on the race including from supporters of the various candidates. If you are interested, see the end of this post for details on submitting a piece.
Without any further ado the top six posts from the two months, in terms of hits, are:
1) Liberal Minister Chrystia Freeland should resign for celebrating her grandfather's Nazi past
The sins of the mother or father, grandmother or grandfather, should never be held against the child...unless they then appear to lie about and celebrate those sins.
Read More!
2) Niki Ashton is the leader the NDP and Canada needs
Guest Editorial by Robert McCarthy
My name is Robert McCarthy from Sudbury, Ontario and I am supporting Niki Ashton to become the next leader of the New Democratic Party of Canada. Like myself, Niki is a proud Democratic Socialist. She is the candidate that I most identify with. Her vision includes free tuition and student debt forgiveness, opposing pipelines where they infringe on Indigenous rights and endanger the environment, and the expansion of public healthcare to include dental care, pharmacare and access to mental health services for all Canadians. These policies are perfectly in line with what I believe.
Read More!
3) We don't need a populist left, post-identity politics left or 'alt left' to fight the rise of the far right, we just need a left
Have you heard the news?
The "left" is "out of touch" with the pulse of what is going on in the United States and North America more broadly because insert left academic or commentator/insert left publication says this must be true due to Trump's victory in the US Presidential race.
4) Sid Ryan hits all the right leftist notes in a powerful video that leaves us asking why he is not running
Sid Ryan, the seemingly divisive former leader of the Ontario Federation of Labour (OFL), has been flirting with the idea of running for the leadership of the NDP for a few months now.
Read More!
5) University of Calgary Conservatives plan to mark International Women's Day with a men's rights movie
The University of Calgary Conservative Party club has decided to team up with the campus Wildrose Party club to honour International Women's Day...by screening a movie praising the noxious anti-feminist Men's Rights extremist movement.
Seriously.
Read More!
6) The backlash against Niki Ashton from anti-Black Lives Matter commentators is what is really off base
Are people really attacking Niki Ashton for taking down a meme due to an objection from Black Lives Matter Vancouver? Apparently, in yet another example of misplaced and wasted outrage serving a right-wing narrative about the chimera of "political correctness", they are!
Read More!
The top food related post for the period was Homestyle Pork Chops in Onion Gravy
Over the coming weeks The Left Chapter is interested in getting different perspectives on the NDP leadership race including from those both inside and outside of the party, from partisans of various candidates (perhaps explaining why), from critics of the race or those who think supporting any of them is perhaps a mistake, from those who would like to see a candidate who has yet to emerge, analysis of the candidates from an objective left perspective, etc.
If you have perspectives about the NDP leadership race specifically that you would like to share in blog/article/editorial form please contact us via theleftchapter@outlook.com
Do you have a left point-of-view or opinion, event or petition, a recipe or a story you want to share?
Send them to The Left Chapter via theleftchapter@outlook.com!
See also: CAFE, Molson Coors Boycott, Road Tolls & more -- December and January on The Left Chapter in review
See also: Canadian Labour, Trump, McMaster & more -- October and November on The Left Chapter in review
Labels:
Black Lives Matter,
Calgary,
Chrystia Freeland,
Niki Ashton,
Sid Ryan
Monday, March 6, 2017
University of Calgary Conservatives plan to mark International Women's Day with a men's rights movie
The University of Calgary Conservative Party club has decided to team up with the campus Wildrose Party club to honour International Women's Day...by screening a movie praising the noxious anti-feminist Men's Rights extremist movement.
Seriously.
It is actually hard to imagine anything so unbelievably ignorant coming from a campus club affiliated with a major Canadian political party that has an interim leader who is a woman, but there you have it. The fellas (and as you will see they really do seem to be fellas) running this group apparently think it is acceptable to do this on a day meant to mark the ongoing struggle for women's equality in Canada and globally.
The movie they are screening is the notorious "documentary" that the Village Voice wrote a review about entitled "Warning: You Can't Unsee 'The Red Pill,' the Documentary About a Filmmaker Who Learns to Love MRAs".
Keep in mind, again, that they are screening this on International Women's Day.
On the event page they are also promoting it with a screen shot that shows a woman who was the target of a years long, vicious and awful online hate campaign.
Classy.
Mind you back in October, 2016 the Conservative Club boasted on their Facebook page "Thanks to all of our club members for making U of C Conservatives biggest Conservative Campus club in Canada!!" and then proceeded to post a bunch of photos of club members (some with Trump t-shirts) which show a striking lack of gender diversity!
Apparently someone in the Wildrose group could not resist sending out an email saying "feminism is cancer" to help promote the event:
This certainly seems to be confirmed by the fact that they have a posted an apology for the email:
Of course, it would be odd to disavow the email given the documentary's content!
So, in the end one has to wonder, do the leaders of the federal Conservative Party and the provincial Wildrose Party think it acceptable for their University of Calgary campus clubs to screen this film on IWD?
The fact that they would even consider doing so says just what these club members think about women.
Update: Since this was posted, the Wildrose Club has withdrawn from co-hosting the event according to CBC News.
Update: The Conservative club has followed suit and pulled out of the event as well due to bad publicity surrounding the Wildrose email. But the question of why they would feel it was OK to screen this film on International Women's Day in the first place remains.
Labels:
Alberta,
Calgary,
Conservatives,
Rona Ambrose,
Wildrose Party
Saturday, April 2, 2016
Bernie Sanders, the Ghomeshi Verdict, the Calgary Police & more - February and March on The Left Chapter in review
The months of February and March saw 40 total posts of various kinds on The Left Chapter and very strong numbers from our readership!
The posts were very diverse, ranging from Toronto writer A.M.'s powerful "Open Letter" to American Democrats to 14 year old Nathaniel Laxer's revisiting of the Communist flags of the game Victoria 2, from a trip back to the Mimico of the turn of the last century to a look at some stunningly evocative photos of Soviet era Moscow in the 1950s.
Without any further ado, here are the top six posts, in terms of hits, for the months of February and March.
1) It's Not Over -- Bernie Sanders releases campaign ad unlike any you have ever seen
Yesterday, the Bernie Sanders campaign for the Democratic Presidential nomination released a campaign ad unlike any you have ever seen.
There has never been a political ad for the candidate of a mainstream party like this in either the United States or Canada ever. Period.
Read More!
2) Jian Ghomeshi's acquittal and the systemic misogyny of the justice system
As many have suspected would happen, Jian Ghomeshi was acquitted today.
The verdict, sadly, is not much of a surprise and is grotesquely indicative of how in sexual assault trials it is still really the victims who are on trial. In this case, the treatment of the three complainants shows this very clearly.
Read More!
3) Introducing the Calgary Police Service's "Diversity Unit" -- led by four middle-aged white guys!
Fun fact everyone -- The Calgary Police Service has a diversity unit!
Read More!
4) Toronto budget prioritizes policing -- Yet again
When it comes to the passage of John Tory's second "austerity-without-the Ford spectacle" budget of his term, there is a least the small silver lining that -- unlike in the farce of last year's near budget unanimity -- this time 9 Councillors voted against it.
33, however, voted for it.
Read More!
5) Soviet Storm -- An epic Russian TV documentary account of WWII in the East
In 2011, Russian television produced an epic documentary look at World War II in the East -- known to the Russians as the Great Patriotic War -- called Soviet Storm.
Consisting of 18 parts, Soviet Storm follows the titanic and brutal struggle between Hitler's genocidal Nazi invaders and the Red Army and people of the USSR. It details the disastrous start to the war, through to the siege of Leningrad and battle for Moscow, to the turning of the tide at Stalingrad and Kursk, to the drive to victory in Berlin. It even has episodes dealing specifically with the partisan struggle, the air war, naval war (yes, there was one), espionage and battles and fronts you have likely not heard of.
Read More!
6) In praise of the "social justice warrior"
Have you heard lately about some "social justice warrior" hysterically standing up against sexism, racism or some other oppression that a wide variety of people seem to think we should all be more polite and demure about opposing if we can be bothered to at all?
Well, of course you have. The term social justice warrior is the new version of the old "politically correct" canard. It has become pervasive.
Read More!
The top food post for the period was "12-Hour Slow Cooked Caribbean-Style Oxtail"
Do you have a left point-of-view or opinion, a recipe or a story you want to share?
Send them to The Left Chapter via theleftchapter@outlook.com!
See also: Racist refugee myths, NDP delusions, Tom Mulcair & more -- December and January on The Left Chapter in review
See also: Racist Memes, Andrew Coyne, the NDP's Disaster & more! -- The Top Ten Posts and the year on The Left Chapter in review
The posts were very diverse, ranging from Toronto writer A.M.'s powerful "Open Letter" to American Democrats to 14 year old Nathaniel Laxer's revisiting of the Communist flags of the game Victoria 2, from a trip back to the Mimico of the turn of the last century to a look at some stunningly evocative photos of Soviet era Moscow in the 1950s.
Without any further ado, here are the top six posts, in terms of hits, for the months of February and March.
1) It's Not Over -- Bernie Sanders releases campaign ad unlike any you have ever seen
Yesterday, the Bernie Sanders campaign for the Democratic Presidential nomination released a campaign ad unlike any you have ever seen.
There has never been a political ad for the candidate of a mainstream party like this in either the United States or Canada ever. Period.
Read More!
2) Jian Ghomeshi's acquittal and the systemic misogyny of the justice system
As many have suspected would happen, Jian Ghomeshi was acquitted today.
The verdict, sadly, is not much of a surprise and is grotesquely indicative of how in sexual assault trials it is still really the victims who are on trial. In this case, the treatment of the three complainants shows this very clearly.
Read More!
3) Introducing the Calgary Police Service's "Diversity Unit" -- led by four middle-aged white guys!
Fun fact everyone -- The Calgary Police Service has a diversity unit!
Read More!
4) Toronto budget prioritizes policing -- Yet again
When it comes to the passage of John Tory's second "austerity-without-the Ford spectacle" budget of his term, there is a least the small silver lining that -- unlike in the farce of last year's near budget unanimity -- this time 9 Councillors voted against it.
33, however, voted for it.
Read More!
5) Soviet Storm -- An epic Russian TV documentary account of WWII in the East
In 2011, Russian television produced an epic documentary look at World War II in the East -- known to the Russians as the Great Patriotic War -- called Soviet Storm.
Consisting of 18 parts, Soviet Storm follows the titanic and brutal struggle between Hitler's genocidal Nazi invaders and the Red Army and people of the USSR. It details the disastrous start to the war, through to the siege of Leningrad and battle for Moscow, to the turning of the tide at Stalingrad and Kursk, to the drive to victory in Berlin. It even has episodes dealing specifically with the partisan struggle, the air war, naval war (yes, there was one), espionage and battles and fronts you have likely not heard of.
Read More!
6) In praise of the "social justice warrior"
Have you heard lately about some "social justice warrior" hysterically standing up against sexism, racism or some other oppression that a wide variety of people seem to think we should all be more polite and demure about opposing if we can be bothered to at all?
Well, of course you have. The term social justice warrior is the new version of the old "politically correct" canard. It has become pervasive.
Read More!
The top food post for the period was "12-Hour Slow Cooked Caribbean-Style Oxtail"
Do you have a left point-of-view or opinion, a recipe or a story you want to share?
Send them to The Left Chapter via theleftchapter@outlook.com!
See also: Racist refugee myths, NDP delusions, Tom Mulcair & more -- December and January on The Left Chapter in review
See also: Racist Memes, Andrew Coyne, the NDP's Disaster & more! -- The Top Ten Posts and the year on The Left Chapter in review
Labels:
Bernie Sanders,
Calgary,
Calgary Police Service,
Jian Ghomeshi,
Nathaniel Laxer,
social justice warrior,
Soviet Union,
Toronto,
Toronto City Council
Tuesday, March 1, 2016
Introducing the Calgary Police Service's "Diversity Unit" -- led by four middle-aged white guys!
Fun fact everyone -- The Calgary Police Service has a diversity unit!
What is the function of this unit?
Sounds good, though it is a bit self-evident that only the police service itself can be "a leader in fostering awareness and understanding, both within the Police Service and between the Service and Calgary’s diverse communities."
So who are the fine folks who are standing up to meet this challenge and promote diversity?
Well there is this middle-aged white guy:
He heads up the South East Asia portfolio. He loves the movie Gladiator, and really wants to try new food!
Oh...and he thinks there might be a language barrier issue with his post.
Then there is this middle-aged white guy:
He is dealing with the Caribbean and Latin Americas portfolio. He sports a big ass cowboy hat and wants to make people happy.
What a truly diverse bunch. How can there be any doubt about the sincerity and desire of Calgary's police to reach out and build bridges?
I mean, it is not like having a single -- just one -- officer in the "diversity unit" who was not middle-aged, white and male actually matters.
These officers will show that when it comes to diversity, no one leads like the Calgary Police Service!
What is the function of this unit?
The Calgary Police Service is a leader in fostering awareness and understanding, both within the Police Service and between the Service and Calgary’s diverse communities. We are instrumental in preserving the quality of life in our community by maintaining Calgary as a secure place in which to live.
We strive to improve awareness and understanding, both inside the organization and externally. By building bridges of respect with Calgary’s diverse communities, we ultimately improve the quality of life for citizens through social development.
Sounds good, though it is a bit self-evident that only the police service itself can be "a leader in fostering awareness and understanding, both within the Police Service and between the Service and Calgary’s diverse communities."
So who are the fine folks who are standing up to meet this challenge and promote diversity?
Well there is this middle-aged white guy:
He heads up the South East Asia portfolio. He loves the movie Gladiator, and really wants to try new food!
Oh...and he thinks there might be a language barrier issue with his post.
Then there is this middle-aged white guy:
His portfolio is South Asia. He loves hiking, grew up in New Brunswick and hopes to overcome people's fears of police that stem from the "old country".
Then there is this middle-aged white guy:
He "identifies" as straight but is, of course, heading up the Gender and Sexual Diversity portfolio. He also loves sports and golf.
And finally there is this middle-aged white guy:
What a truly diverse bunch. How can there be any doubt about the sincerity and desire of Calgary's police to reach out and build bridges?
I mean, it is not like having a single -- just one -- officer in the "diversity unit" who was not middle-aged, white and male actually matters.
These officers will show that when it comes to diversity, no one leads like the Calgary Police Service!
Saturday, August 1, 2015
July: Xenophobes, Olivia Chow, Eve Adams, Naheed Nenshi & more -- The month on The Left Chapter in review
July had, with vacations and so on, the least number of posts for any month so far on The Left Chapter with 25 posts of various types. Despite this, however, it was our strongest month for views.
This month, as did June, had another record setter -- the post on the BC NDP's foreign worker meme had more hits than any other post in The Left Chapter's history and has remanded in the "Popular Posts" column everyday since it was posted on the 12th.
Here, in order, are the top five posts on The Left Chapter for the month of July:
1) BC NDP posts a meme about "foreign" workers -- Xenophobes show up in approval
There is a wing of the left -- and especially within the mainstream "social democratic" party, the NDP -- that thinks that the path to power is in part paved by pandering to what are traditionally right-wing populist narratives.
Read More!
2) Tom Mulcair holds a press conference...and, presto, Olivia Chow is the "official" NDP candidate
So a funny thing happened on the march to the New Jerusalem today.
Tom Mulcair and Olivia Chow held a news conference announcing that Chow was going to be the NDP candidate federally in the new riding of Spadina-Fort York and, guess what, she was, then, the candidate!
Read More!
3) Eve Adams shows that the Trudeau jig is up
One almost has to feel sorry for Eve Adams at the moment of her humiliating and ignominious defeat in her quest for the Liberal nomination in Eglinton-Lawrence -- a defeat that both shows the new weakness of the slowly tanking Liberal leader Trudeau and that would have been unthinkable a few short months ago.
Read More!
4) On Naheed Nenshi and the Importance of Revitalizing Candid Inquiry on the Left
By Carol-Anne Hudson
On 25 October 2010 Naheed Nenshi was elected Mayor of Calgary. His come-from-behind electoral win was, largely, the result of a populist rejection of the front runner and long-time city councillor Ric McIver who was thought to be out-of-touch with the city’s changing demographic landscape and considered by many as an abrasive, torpid, schismatic, and immovable extreme right-wing conservative. Aware of rising ‘Anyone But McInver’ sentiments, especially among young voters, Nenshi shrewdly crafted a public image of himself as an approachable, energetic, cosmopolitan, progressive social unifier and urban modernizer -- a ‘hero of the common people’ -- the antithesis of McIver.
Read More!
5) A brief note on cynicism and Canadian politics
The other day I received an email from Tom Mulcair, leader of the federal NDP.
Now, of course, it was not actually an email from him, but was, rather, one of those countless emails the NDP sends out weekly (and even daily) to those who are on its email contact list.
Read More!
The number one food post for the month of July was the nostalgic look back at Mme. Benoit looking back nostalgically -- Trout in Corn Husks, Pickled Mushrooms & other 19th Century Recipes from Madame Benoit
Do you have a left point-of-view or opinion, a recipe or a story you want to share?
Send them to The Left Chapter via theleftchapter@outlook.com!
Check out our review for the month of June!: June: Leadnow, Anti-Choice Extremists, the Greens and more -- The month on The Left Chapter in review
This month, as did June, had another record setter -- the post on the BC NDP's foreign worker meme had more hits than any other post in The Left Chapter's history and has remanded in the "Popular Posts" column everyday since it was posted on the 12th.
Here, in order, are the top five posts on The Left Chapter for the month of July:
1) BC NDP posts a meme about "foreign" workers -- Xenophobes show up in approval
There is a wing of the left -- and especially within the mainstream "social democratic" party, the NDP -- that thinks that the path to power is in part paved by pandering to what are traditionally right-wing populist narratives.
Read More!
2) Tom Mulcair holds a press conference...and, presto, Olivia Chow is the "official" NDP candidate
So a funny thing happened on the march to the New Jerusalem today.
Tom Mulcair and Olivia Chow held a news conference announcing that Chow was going to be the NDP candidate federally in the new riding of Spadina-Fort York and, guess what, she was, then, the candidate!
Read More!
3) Eve Adams shows that the Trudeau jig is up
One almost has to feel sorry for Eve Adams at the moment of her humiliating and ignominious defeat in her quest for the Liberal nomination in Eglinton-Lawrence -- a defeat that both shows the new weakness of the slowly tanking Liberal leader Trudeau and that would have been unthinkable a few short months ago.
Read More!
4) On Naheed Nenshi and the Importance of Revitalizing Candid Inquiry on the Left
By Carol-Anne Hudson
On 25 October 2010 Naheed Nenshi was elected Mayor of Calgary. His come-from-behind electoral win was, largely, the result of a populist rejection of the front runner and long-time city councillor Ric McIver who was thought to be out-of-touch with the city’s changing demographic landscape and considered by many as an abrasive, torpid, schismatic, and immovable extreme right-wing conservative. Aware of rising ‘Anyone But McInver’ sentiments, especially among young voters, Nenshi shrewdly crafted a public image of himself as an approachable, energetic, cosmopolitan, progressive social unifier and urban modernizer -- a ‘hero of the common people’ -- the antithesis of McIver.
Read More!
5) A brief note on cynicism and Canadian politics
The other day I received an email from Tom Mulcair, leader of the federal NDP.
Now, of course, it was not actually an email from him, but was, rather, one of those countless emails the NDP sends out weekly (and even daily) to those who are on its email contact list.
Read More!
The number one food post for the month of July was the nostalgic look back at Mme. Benoit looking back nostalgically -- Trout in Corn Husks, Pickled Mushrooms & other 19th Century Recipes from Madame Benoit
Do you have a left point-of-view or opinion, a recipe or a story you want to share?
Send them to The Left Chapter via theleftchapter@outlook.com!
Check out our review for the month of June!: June: Leadnow, Anti-Choice Extremists, the Greens and more -- The month on The Left Chapter in review
Labels:
BC NDP,
Calgary,
Carol-Anne Hudson,
Eve Adams,
Justin Trudeau,
Liberals,
Mme. Benoit,
Naheed Nenshi,
NDP,
Olivia Chow,
Ric McIver,
Tom Mulcair
Thursday, July 23, 2015
On Naheed Nenshi and the Importance of Revitalizing Candid Inquiry on the Left
By Carol-Anne Hudson
On 25 October 2010 Naheed Nenshi was elected Mayor of Calgary. His come-from-behind electoral win was, largely, the result of a populist rejection of the front runner and long-time city councillor Ric McIver who was thought to be out-of-touch with the city’s changing demographic landscape and considered by many as an abrasive, torpid, schismatic, and immovable extreme right-wing conservative. Aware of rising ‘Anyone But McInver’ sentiments, especially among young voters, Nenshi shrewdly crafted a public image of himself as an approachable, energetic, cosmopolitan, progressive social unifier and urban modernizer -- a ‘hero of the common people’ -- the antithesis of McIver.
However, the reality of politics on the ground since the 2010 election suggests that Nenshi has not only failed to demonstrate any of these much vaunted qualities but has shown a complete disregard for the day-to-day economic struggles of the average person -- especially the poor and working class. Further, in his approach to social development and urban innovation Nenshi has revealed himself to be cut from the same cloth as McIver -- that is to say, he has been divisive, inflexible, controlling, exclusive, and a dogmatic champion of free-markets. Consequently, Nenshi has deepened and reinforced social, economic, and political hierarchies within the city as well as undermined grassroots’ efforts to strengthen social solidarity and advance alternatives.
Yet, despite the preponderance of evidence that casts serious doubt on Nenshi’s bona fides as a progressive social unifier and urban modernizer, his Worship continues to attract considerable admiration and support, especially amongst the social democratic left. It is particularly curious, given a dramatic rise in homelessness, poverty, and social exclusion in Calgary during the last five years, that many of Nenshi’s social democratic supporters are prominent Toronto-based community leaders in the areas of social housing, Aboriginal advocacy, women’s rights, public transit, and organized labour. These community activists hold Nenshi aloft as a bold, exciting, and morally responsible political leader. This raises two questions: why have so many (Toronto-based) social democrats bestowed upon Nenshi the mantle of progressive urban superhero when the facts show him to be a blustering, overbearing, authoritarian neo-liberal? And, what is the impact of such support on broader debates about progressive policymaking?
From the outset, Mayor Nenshi was drawn to the media like a moth to a flame. The Korda photo of a beret-wearing Che Guevara has not seen such a challenger for iconic status in Canada. The media darling -- receding chin resolutely tilted towards the heavens -- adorned the front pages of most major newspapers across the country with pithy captions that seem to stir the hopes of even the most cynical and battle weary social activist. One Toronto Star reader commented: “You can’t help but be cheered by him.”
Nenshi traveled the confederation, was a frequent and lauded guest on national evening news broadcasts, and was a much sought after motivational speaker, especially among the non-profit sector in Toronto. His message was simple: we must move our cities into the 21st century!
According to Nenshi, and elaborated in his 2010 Purple Revolution campaign manifesto, this included: modernizing public infrastructure (roads, transportation, and energy supplies), addressing inner city development (revitalization of decaying neighbourhoods), adopting strong environmental regulations and ethical procurement practices, and above all, eliminating poverty and social inequalities. Nenshi’s prescribed method to deliver these public goods -- inclusive policy inputs, development, and implementation, that is to say, the grassroots will lead the way forward.
For his proselytizing, in 2013 Nenshi was named by Maclean’s Magazine as the second most powerful man in Canada (after Stephen Harper) and in 2014 awarded the somewhat obscure prize of World’s Best Mayor. Where Nenshi was concerned, Torontonians, under siege by the petulant and drug-addled Rob Ford, seemed to have only one question, “when is he coming to save us?” Had MacLean’s, the WBM jury, or Torontonians done their due diligence they may have taken quite a different attitude.
Nenshi’s 2010 Purple Revolution campaign manifesto included, among other things, promises for sweeping changes to public transportation, inner-city neighbourhoods, and the promotion of social cohesion. However, once elected and despite the fact that a majority of Calgarians were strongly opposed to the construction of an airport tunnel (a 600 metre underpass from Calgary’s International Airport along the Deerfoot Trail to the downtown core at a cost of $300 million primarily to serve the needs of foreign oil executives), Nenshi adamantly refused to consider the less costly and more environmentally friendly alternative -- a dedicated HOV (high-occupancy vehicle) lane with an estimated price tag of between $20 and $40 million. He also back-tracked on promised LRT expansion into the city’s densely populated and underserved (and largely low-income) southeast quadrant. He failed to adopt a low-fare transit plan for low-income residents and has been a laggard in developing bike infrastructure in the downtown core as well as converting the LRT to a renewable energy source (wind power). Where positive changes have occurred (e.g., ethical procurement policies), they have been minimal, not open to public audit, and, for the most part, can be attributed to policies initiated by his predecessors.
Likewise, Nenshi’s approach to inner-city development -- namely, creating affordable housing and addressing poverty and social cohesion in the most diverse and poorest section of the city -- has privileged the interests of profit-seeking land developers, investment capital, and a small group of middle-class (largely white) professionals over the needs of the majority -- poor and working-class inner-city residents (comprised mostly of newcomers, Aboriginal, and racialized populations). For example, during the last five years Nenshi has smoothed the way for an explosion of high-end, low-density condos along the river-front through the use of a multi-pronged social cleansing policy which includes: revising Good Neighbour agreements to prohibit social service providers from feeding the homeless in the downtown core; relocating the city’s largest inner-city homeless shelter (situated on a prime river-front site) to an industrial area outside the downtown core; and, failing to adopt a secondary suites policy which would greatly expand the number of affordable living spaces in the downtown core.
Perhaps the strongest evidence for Nenshi’s draconian social cleansing program was his unique approach to developing Calgary’s first poverty reduction strategy. Unlike poverty reduction strategies developed in major urban centres elsewhere in Canada, Nenshi shut-out the bureaucracy, major stakeholders, and especially the poor during all phases of development. At great odds with the bureaucracy, who were advocating for a comprehensive progressive strategy, Nenshi personally selected two people to design the policy with clear instructions on what the strategy should look like. On this, Nenshi set limits to who would be consulted (e.g., small church-based groups) and policy parameters that excluded a focus on women (among the poorest and most underpaid in Canada), Aboriginals, income support recipients, and newcomers. The result was a marginal technical fix on existing service delivery aimed at the working poor (largely unskilled men) through the creation of community-based ‘hubs’. Implementation was out-sourced to a small business non-profit that emphasizes micro-credit programs and entrepreneurialization of the poor. To be certain that the focus of his anti-poverty policy remained exclusively on service delivery Nenshi came out strongly against adopting a living wage and refused to discuss job creation.
Clearly, Nenshi is a loyal agent of private accumulation and the propertied class. And according to Philip Sayton in his new book “Mayors Gone Bad”, Nenshi has not accomplished anything, is unpopular with city residents, has the record for losing the most votes on council (ever), and is ‘overbearing, arrogant, authoritarian, and bumptious’, in a word – a bully. So, how is it that Nenshi has acquired such a popular following among the Left, especially in Toronto often considered a bastion of progressiveness?
Philip Sayton offers some insight into this question. He suggests that the need for optimism in these dark times may blind some to the reality of politics on the ground. This seems to play out where social democratic community leaders in Toronto are concerned. When pressed on why they support Nenshi their responses often go something like this: he (Nenshi) is friendly, likeable, a good speaker, clever, nice, light-hearted and so on.
These progressive civic leaders do not give us legitimate reasons for supporting a right-wing anti-democratic tyrant. They are, in fact, arguing for improved civility in the public square. That is, they are making an appeal to social utility – it would be better for society if we were nicer. Such an appeal (rewarding niceness) makes these people seem more open-minded than they really are. Nowhere in their defence of Nenshi (and other political leaders like him) is there the faintest attempt to provide evidence to prove the truth of their claims. They are proposing, in effect, that our political representatives do not have to be effective progressive leaders, we just have to believe it is so – blind faith. We cannot take these people seriously.
The objections to this kind of argumentation from progressives are so many that it is difficult to know where to begin. Foremost, perhaps, is that progressive such as these are introducing or creating taboos around what constitutes legitimate debate. This not only minimizes the importance of rigorous and candid inquiry, but ostracizes free thinkers – those who take decidedly different (progressive) positions. In many ways, it is an act of self-preservation, that is, these community leaders seek to preserve a position (social democratic) by looking past those parts which do not serve their ends. What is needed to counter this growing trend on the left is an attitude of scientific inquiry.
Canada is in considerable peril. The country is on the brink of environmental, economic, and social collapse. Some Canadians have responded to these crises by denying the gravity of the situation while others recognize the immediacy of our troubles yet look past our political leaders’ inability to respond effectively to them. To this end, any appeal to civility from the left rather than vigorously confronting those mandated to take action discourages candid inquiry and impairs intellectual rigour.
Put otherwise, if we focus on a social utility approach (niceness and a non-confrontational disposition) to policy-making our problems would not be solved. Rather, it would be a dangerous delusion because it misleads people whose thinking might otherwise be fruitful and this stands in the way of developing valid policy solutions. The question, therefore, does not concern civility but intellectual integrity. By this is meant, we must decide the difficult questions in accordance with the evidence. Reasoned and informed debate is far more likely to benefit the country than any emotional plea to social virtues (niceness) which has no basis in reality and, at the end of the day, offers little actual social utility.
In the end, indifference to the truth in favour of an appeal to social virtue is extremely dangerous and cannot save us from disaster. It is opposition to prevailing consensus that effects improvements and will move us forward. That is, genuine social progress depends upon dissent, reasoned debate, and intellectual inquiry. Responding to the issues of the day on the basis of niceness may protect us from crude contact with reality, but it will ensure that as little as possible shall be known about the subject. In the best case, an appeal to civility prevents the facts from coming out. In the worse case, people will be duped into becoming the unpaid hirelings of weak and self-serving politicians by policing the boundaries of what is considered acceptable political discourse. This of course, silences free thinking and flattens the political landscape. Getting at the facts is often very difficult, messy, and may lead to even greater anxieties and uncertainties. We may not find the answers to these difficult questions and solutions, therefore, will be delayed until more can be known, but ignorance is never the answer, however nicely it is framed.
Carol-Anne Hudson is completing a PhD in political science at McMaster University. Her research focuses on comparative social policy, specifically poverty reduction, living wages, and business participation in social policy renewal. She is from Calgary and now resides in Toronto.
Do you have a left point-of-view or opinion, a recipe or a story you want to share?
Send them to The Left Chapter via theleftchapter@outlook.com!
See Also: 42-2: John Tory, Toronto City Council and the austerity consensus
On 25 October 2010 Naheed Nenshi was elected Mayor of Calgary. His come-from-behind electoral win was, largely, the result of a populist rejection of the front runner and long-time city councillor Ric McIver who was thought to be out-of-touch with the city’s changing demographic landscape and considered by many as an abrasive, torpid, schismatic, and immovable extreme right-wing conservative. Aware of rising ‘Anyone But McInver’ sentiments, especially among young voters, Nenshi shrewdly crafted a public image of himself as an approachable, energetic, cosmopolitan, progressive social unifier and urban modernizer -- a ‘hero of the common people’ -- the antithesis of McIver.
However, the reality of politics on the ground since the 2010 election suggests that Nenshi has not only failed to demonstrate any of these much vaunted qualities but has shown a complete disregard for the day-to-day economic struggles of the average person -- especially the poor and working class. Further, in his approach to social development and urban innovation Nenshi has revealed himself to be cut from the same cloth as McIver -- that is to say, he has been divisive, inflexible, controlling, exclusive, and a dogmatic champion of free-markets. Consequently, Nenshi has deepened and reinforced social, economic, and political hierarchies within the city as well as undermined grassroots’ efforts to strengthen social solidarity and advance alternatives.
Yet, despite the preponderance of evidence that casts serious doubt on Nenshi’s bona fides as a progressive social unifier and urban modernizer, his Worship continues to attract considerable admiration and support, especially amongst the social democratic left. It is particularly curious, given a dramatic rise in homelessness, poverty, and social exclusion in Calgary during the last five years, that many of Nenshi’s social democratic supporters are prominent Toronto-based community leaders in the areas of social housing, Aboriginal advocacy, women’s rights, public transit, and organized labour. These community activists hold Nenshi aloft as a bold, exciting, and morally responsible political leader. This raises two questions: why have so many (Toronto-based) social democrats bestowed upon Nenshi the mantle of progressive urban superhero when the facts show him to be a blustering, overbearing, authoritarian neo-liberal? And, what is the impact of such support on broader debates about progressive policymaking?
Nenshi
From the outset, Mayor Nenshi was drawn to the media like a moth to a flame. The Korda photo of a beret-wearing Che Guevara has not seen such a challenger for iconic status in Canada. The media darling -- receding chin resolutely tilted towards the heavens -- adorned the front pages of most major newspapers across the country with pithy captions that seem to stir the hopes of even the most cynical and battle weary social activist. One Toronto Star reader commented: “You can’t help but be cheered by him.”
Nenshi traveled the confederation, was a frequent and lauded guest on national evening news broadcasts, and was a much sought after motivational speaker, especially among the non-profit sector in Toronto. His message was simple: we must move our cities into the 21st century!
According to Nenshi, and elaborated in his 2010 Purple Revolution campaign manifesto, this included: modernizing public infrastructure (roads, transportation, and energy supplies), addressing inner city development (revitalization of decaying neighbourhoods), adopting strong environmental regulations and ethical procurement practices, and above all, eliminating poverty and social inequalities. Nenshi’s prescribed method to deliver these public goods -- inclusive policy inputs, development, and implementation, that is to say, the grassroots will lead the way forward.
For his proselytizing, in 2013 Nenshi was named by Maclean’s Magazine as the second most powerful man in Canada (after Stephen Harper) and in 2014 awarded the somewhat obscure prize of World’s Best Mayor. Where Nenshi was concerned, Torontonians, under siege by the petulant and drug-addled Rob Ford, seemed to have only one question, “when is he coming to save us?” Had MacLean’s, the WBM jury, or Torontonians done their due diligence they may have taken quite a different attitude.
Virtuous Champion of the Poor and Working Class or Tyrannical Profiteer?
Nenshi’s 2010 Purple Revolution campaign manifesto included, among other things, promises for sweeping changes to public transportation, inner-city neighbourhoods, and the promotion of social cohesion. However, once elected and despite the fact that a majority of Calgarians were strongly opposed to the construction of an airport tunnel (a 600 metre underpass from Calgary’s International Airport along the Deerfoot Trail to the downtown core at a cost of $300 million primarily to serve the needs of foreign oil executives), Nenshi adamantly refused to consider the less costly and more environmentally friendly alternative -- a dedicated HOV (high-occupancy vehicle) lane with an estimated price tag of between $20 and $40 million. He also back-tracked on promised LRT expansion into the city’s densely populated and underserved (and largely low-income) southeast quadrant. He failed to adopt a low-fare transit plan for low-income residents and has been a laggard in developing bike infrastructure in the downtown core as well as converting the LRT to a renewable energy source (wind power). Where positive changes have occurred (e.g., ethical procurement policies), they have been minimal, not open to public audit, and, for the most part, can be attributed to policies initiated by his predecessors.
Likewise, Nenshi’s approach to inner-city development -- namely, creating affordable housing and addressing poverty and social cohesion in the most diverse and poorest section of the city -- has privileged the interests of profit-seeking land developers, investment capital, and a small group of middle-class (largely white) professionals over the needs of the majority -- poor and working-class inner-city residents (comprised mostly of newcomers, Aboriginal, and racialized populations). For example, during the last five years Nenshi has smoothed the way for an explosion of high-end, low-density condos along the river-front through the use of a multi-pronged social cleansing policy which includes: revising Good Neighbour agreements to prohibit social service providers from feeding the homeless in the downtown core; relocating the city’s largest inner-city homeless shelter (situated on a prime river-front site) to an industrial area outside the downtown core; and, failing to adopt a secondary suites policy which would greatly expand the number of affordable living spaces in the downtown core.
Perhaps the strongest evidence for Nenshi’s draconian social cleansing program was his unique approach to developing Calgary’s first poverty reduction strategy. Unlike poverty reduction strategies developed in major urban centres elsewhere in Canada, Nenshi shut-out the bureaucracy, major stakeholders, and especially the poor during all phases of development. At great odds with the bureaucracy, who were advocating for a comprehensive progressive strategy, Nenshi personally selected two people to design the policy with clear instructions on what the strategy should look like. On this, Nenshi set limits to who would be consulted (e.g., small church-based groups) and policy parameters that excluded a focus on women (among the poorest and most underpaid in Canada), Aboriginals, income support recipients, and newcomers. The result was a marginal technical fix on existing service delivery aimed at the working poor (largely unskilled men) through the creation of community-based ‘hubs’. Implementation was out-sourced to a small business non-profit that emphasizes micro-credit programs and entrepreneurialization of the poor. To be certain that the focus of his anti-poverty policy remained exclusively on service delivery Nenshi came out strongly against adopting a living wage and refused to discuss job creation.
Clearly, Nenshi is a loyal agent of private accumulation and the propertied class. And according to Philip Sayton in his new book “Mayors Gone Bad”, Nenshi has not accomplished anything, is unpopular with city residents, has the record for losing the most votes on council (ever), and is ‘overbearing, arrogant, authoritarian, and bumptious’, in a word – a bully. So, how is it that Nenshi has acquired such a popular following among the Left, especially in Toronto often considered a bastion of progressiveness?
Presentation over Substance?
Philip Sayton offers some insight into this question. He suggests that the need for optimism in these dark times may blind some to the reality of politics on the ground. This seems to play out where social democratic community leaders in Toronto are concerned. When pressed on why they support Nenshi their responses often go something like this: he (Nenshi) is friendly, likeable, a good speaker, clever, nice, light-hearted and so on.
These progressive civic leaders do not give us legitimate reasons for supporting a right-wing anti-democratic tyrant. They are, in fact, arguing for improved civility in the public square. That is, they are making an appeal to social utility – it would be better for society if we were nicer. Such an appeal (rewarding niceness) makes these people seem more open-minded than they really are. Nowhere in their defence of Nenshi (and other political leaders like him) is there the faintest attempt to provide evidence to prove the truth of their claims. They are proposing, in effect, that our political representatives do not have to be effective progressive leaders, we just have to believe it is so – blind faith. We cannot take these people seriously.
The objections to this kind of argumentation from progressives are so many that it is difficult to know where to begin. Foremost, perhaps, is that progressive such as these are introducing or creating taboos around what constitutes legitimate debate. This not only minimizes the importance of rigorous and candid inquiry, but ostracizes free thinkers – those who take decidedly different (progressive) positions. In many ways, it is an act of self-preservation, that is, these community leaders seek to preserve a position (social democratic) by looking past those parts which do not serve their ends. What is needed to counter this growing trend on the left is an attitude of scientific inquiry.
Conclusion: Can An Appeal to ‘Niceness’ Cure Our Troubles?
Canada is in considerable peril. The country is on the brink of environmental, economic, and social collapse. Some Canadians have responded to these crises by denying the gravity of the situation while others recognize the immediacy of our troubles yet look past our political leaders’ inability to respond effectively to them. To this end, any appeal to civility from the left rather than vigorously confronting those mandated to take action discourages candid inquiry and impairs intellectual rigour.
Put otherwise, if we focus on a social utility approach (niceness and a non-confrontational disposition) to policy-making our problems would not be solved. Rather, it would be a dangerous delusion because it misleads people whose thinking might otherwise be fruitful and this stands in the way of developing valid policy solutions. The question, therefore, does not concern civility but intellectual integrity. By this is meant, we must decide the difficult questions in accordance with the evidence. Reasoned and informed debate is far more likely to benefit the country than any emotional plea to social virtues (niceness) which has no basis in reality and, at the end of the day, offers little actual social utility.
In the end, indifference to the truth in favour of an appeal to social virtue is extremely dangerous and cannot save us from disaster. It is opposition to prevailing consensus that effects improvements and will move us forward. That is, genuine social progress depends upon dissent, reasoned debate, and intellectual inquiry. Responding to the issues of the day on the basis of niceness may protect us from crude contact with reality, but it will ensure that as little as possible shall be known about the subject. In the best case, an appeal to civility prevents the facts from coming out. In the worse case, people will be duped into becoming the unpaid hirelings of weak and self-serving politicians by policing the boundaries of what is considered acceptable political discourse. This of course, silences free thinking and flattens the political landscape. Getting at the facts is often very difficult, messy, and may lead to even greater anxieties and uncertainties. We may not find the answers to these difficult questions and solutions, therefore, will be delayed until more can be known, but ignorance is never the answer, however nicely it is framed.
Carol-Anne Hudson is completing a PhD in political science at McMaster University. Her research focuses on comparative social policy, specifically poverty reduction, living wages, and business participation in social policy renewal. She is from Calgary and now resides in Toronto.
Do you have a left point-of-view or opinion, a recipe or a story you want to share?
Send them to The Left Chapter via theleftchapter@outlook.com!
See Also: 42-2: John Tory, Toronto City Council and the austerity consensus
Labels:
Calgary,
Carol-Anne Hudson,
Naheed Nenshi,
Philip Sayton,
Ric McIver
Thursday, May 14, 2015
The Art of the Hamburger f. The Calgary Cheeseburger, Toronto Turkey Burger, Vancouver Venison Burger & Nova Scotia Salmon Burgers! Vintage Cookbook TBT
Vintage Cookbook: The Art of the Hamburger, Elizabeth Wolf-CohenPublication Details: Chartwell Books, 1996
This terrific cookbook from the 90's takes a comprehensive look at that fixture of North American cuisine, the hamburger!
Full of terrific retro illustrations and photos of hamburger related memorabilia, the book does not simply tread the familiar ground of the classic ground beef variety, but also covers burgers made from any number of other meats or fish. It has a wide array of featured techniques and cool or off-beat ideas as well as a section on classic side dishes and condiments.
One neat aspect to the book is that the recipes are divided by North American geography and named for cities, regions, etc. -- and they include Canadian themed recipes, four of which we share today.
We are also including their overview of the history of the burger.
If you are a fan of burgers, this one is really a must to track down.
(click on images to enlarge)
Labels:
Calgary,
Hamburgers,
Nova Scotia,
salmon,
Toronto,
turkey,
Vancouver,
venison,
Vintage Cookbook Throwback Thursday,
Vintage Cookbooks
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)























